I have a spare 80GB IDE Barracude drive connected to my computer as a slave. I only use it for keeping backups. Since keeping it connected at all times uses power as well is becoming prone to virus attacks, I was wondering if it is safe to unplug the power cable while still keeping the data cable connected. I don't really want to unplug the data cable everytime, its easier to just pull the power cable out.
I just want to know whether its safe (for the hard disk) to keep the system running with its data cable connected and the power cable unplugged.
Thank you for any help.
Bad advice, !! he has PATA drive.!
only the Esata external is hot swappable. as is the old SCSI HDD.
if it has a molex connector , HDD, power, do not hot swap this connector, as you damage the logic, the logic does not allow instant power ups, (hot wiring) it does not.
when you do that the rise time is near the speed of light and the
chips can latch up , then burn.
PATA. when you power down and pull the power connector, dead.
then leave the data cable (parallel cable ribbon) connected
this loads the buss,in an illegal way, this causes other devices on the buss to fail, Data corruptions, like the DVD, CDRom, or the other
hard drive, (i run 2 drives , since 1981 with first ever pc.) IBM.
i have an Esata external drive 2Tb, AND IS hot swappable. RTM.
first read the data sheet on you HDD, see that page?
at seagate? hot swapping power that old drive is not good.
hot swapping data, will no cause damage like above, but will corrupt data, i see tech in the shop wondering why the windows install disc
hangs, i point the the HDD , there, with no power.....
100 of times, ive shown them....
DVD on same cable is dead power drive.
same with 2 HDD on same cable,
some hard drives float the i/o buss and others do not , with power
removed, the data sheet covers this..
A smart tech assumes no float , unless you like , chasing tail all day.
if you run this back up disk on seperate HDD port, MB conn.just never hot wire swap the HDD. do not.never connect anything electronic, while HOT.USB is one exception as is external Esata.
the op clearly stated, PATA and it is not hot swappable,
last answer to OP PATA , it's safe to you !, but not your data. but do not hot swap any PATA molex do not, i watched a guy install xp 5 times, due to dead PATA drive hanging off the CDrom drive (xp intall cd)
×
It is perfectly safe to remove the power cable from a hard drive but leave the data cable connected. Make sure that whenever you want to connect or disconnect the power cable, your computer has been shut down first. You could do it with the computer powered on as well, but this would not be good practice and you may put errors on your drive.
284 views
Usually answered in minutes!
Thank you Palmbeach. That was fast and precise. Exactly what I was looking for. I will remember your advise about shutting down before plugging or unplugging the power cable.
Thanks again, I really appreciate your help.
with regards,
amit_celebt
better, answer, im A+ tech, retired. never hot sway IDE pata drives, never run 2 drives of any kind with one unpowered as that overloads the data buss and cause corruption on the good drive, (see it run slow? sure,) The I/O chips connected must have power.
this rule depends on the type I/O port, there are many, SSCI/PATA/ESATA, or avanced Esata , but if using PATA and using the same cable for both drives, pulling power to one will cause data corruption, read the manual of you HDD (or cd/dvd rom) to learn why. The I/o chips of many load the buss. with no power, i can prove this with data sheets, of same.
hot switching power on devices will blow the chips fast. the exceptions are, SCSI and Esata. hot switch a DC buss is bad practice unless the device was designed for such actions.
the sata is native hotswap, (may not the controller when the surge hits it, huh)
the chips on most PATA when one hot connects the Molex, cause the chips to avelance and the blow up. I worked in test engineering for 15 years and know this well. on the hot swap drives snubbers are used to stop this instantainous rise times hot swapped.
i have esata on my servers, that can be left connected and powered down, (backup) in the old days (pata)we had a special tray and power regultor, that tri-stated the i/o buss and used softpower up and down power drivers, protecting the sensative PATA chips. these are no longer sold. so if using PATA, power down and pull the data cable. if green ?, pull both and power back up.
×