2009 Mini Cooper S Logo
b
buddy little Posted on Feb 11, 2014
Answered by a Fixya Expert

Trustworthy Expert Solutions

At Fixya.com, our trusted experts are meticulously vetted and possess extensive experience in their respective fields. Backed by a community of knowledgeable professionals, our platform ensures that the solutions provided are thoroughly researched and validated.

View Our Top Experts

Engine Surge when cold

When started cold the engine will surge and check engine light is on

1 Answer

Larry Blais

Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Legend:

An expert who has written 200 answers of more than 400 characters.

  • Expert 331 Answers
  • Posted on Mar 03, 2014
Larry Blais
Expert
Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Legend:

An expert who has written 200 answers of more than 400 characters.

Joined: Feb 28, 2014
Answers
331
Questions
0
Helped
100888
Points
761

Since the engine light is on, you need to have the code/s read. There are different causes for your symptoms. This may be related to EGR valve performance, oil flow. vacuum leak, idle air control valve, or fuel flow and pressure. Have the codes read and let me know. The more specific and detailed you can be, the better I can help narrow down your search and repair it. Good luck.

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

0helpful
1answer

89 Chevy shy and Isaac 20 minutes surging why?

not told RPM of surge. (full range of surge)
hot engine surge, or cold or both?
it's old most do this old.
lots of causes.
but why tells the reasons
the IAC is bad or just lost control of engine for 50 other caused.
let say engine as huge vacuum leak
the PCM closes the IAC and can not correct the massive vacuum leak.
or engine goes lean?
or spark misfires so bad IAC can not correcthis.
bad engine, bad spark bad fueling can and will make IAC go dead.
in fact fixing IAC is last, in my book
if all is good just cleaning IAC fixes it. some times.
or replace it.
on old cars the ECU surges the IAC if spec idle speed can not be reached, 800 hot.
0helpful
1answer

My o4 durango starts and runs good to 2200rpm starts to surge any help would be appreciated

surges(no engine told)
hot, and cold engine
any gear, and at idle too. and PARK.?
rpm varies .
surges at cruise,or WOT, wide open throttle?
misfires. ? violent, felt.
scan the PCM when it surges?
lots of causes even cracked brake booster and crazy vacuum leak, now.
and more lots more,
0helpful
2answers

Why does my 2009 gmc 2500hd 6.0l surge on light acceleration after first startup. if i accelrate harder there is no surging. once the engine is warrm there is no surge

Fuel pump needs time to build up pressure . Do this by turning the ignition on for a fer seconds before you start the vehicle
0helpful
1answer

When I start my odyssey it starts surging. I found a small rubber hose on the right side of the engine, but don't know where the other end of the hose goes....Help

WHAT COUNTY???????????????????????????????????
hot engine, cold or both?/// a key question
WHAT ENGINE: ( usa list , ONLY)
2.2 L F22B I4
2.2 L F22B6 I4
2.3 L F23A I4 2.3 L F23A7 I4
the fsm covers this. hose thing.... all hose can be followed,
unless its axle vents on 4wd cars. (they go no where, special)
is surging the only symtom.?
no engine stalls.?
lack of power in any gear or hills.
no misfiring?
no flooding.?
starts easy/?

ok what is surge, that it really is idle controls bad or out of comtrol
1: idle controls bad. (isc dead?)
2: or engine is running way too lean, and ISC cant keep a grip on idle.

easy huh?
and #3 misfiring so bad the idle controls fail.
are all fuses good?
is the CEL lamp glowing , then goes out running engine.
no , the scan it. or do the flash DTC codes trick.

a good tech ,first finds out if the engine holds closed loop status
hot. at idle, if not, he fixes that first.
as he/she knows that idle is the last thing to work right, in EFI.

one other way to get surge is air leaks (aka. vacuum leaks)
if the engine (unsaid option) is MAP based, it will race fast
with any vacuum leak, and it dont take much of a leak
to make the ISC idle controller go nuts.

so repost , hot/cold both questions
and actual RPM numbers. we need numbers
is the dash Tachometer missing. ????
and what engines in car.

all lean engines surge.
all ISC systems can surge if out of control , not all do this. just 1/2
if the ISC surges, it means its trying hard to gain back control.
this is called a software servo loop.
The ECU is programmed to hold rpm near say 800 RPM hot.
and is very digressive in that role.
I have a 91 car that will surge, with any vacuum leaks.
(by design) depends on which engine.
0helpful
1answer

97 toyota surges at an idle

(which engine. ?????)_
as always check all fuses. and scan the ECU for DTCs. first.
there is no need to fix OBD2 cars like 1980 cars (hard rows to hoe)
it can be 2 problems this......
lets fix the easy one first. idle. (and hope for moving issues to fix for free) it idle car is parked, so is 100% safe tests. (not moving)

so it surges at idle.
questions.?
1: hot or cold or both.?
2: low extreme RPM and high at idle.

400 to 800 RPM? surge.
1000 to 2000. what? numbers tell the tale.

first off, idle is the last thing to work right on any engine.

there are many ways to find what is wrong.
fix idle surge way.
i make sure that the engine holds closed LOOP status.
hot idle, if not , i fix that first.
keep in mind if not in closes loop and lean
all lean engine surge and guess what the ISC will add to the surge
because idle is way too slow, so the ECU open the ISC wider
and wider and its still too slow, so the ECU resets the ISC
this cause a worst hunt (surge)
the ECU adjust spark time and the ISC to get 800 rpm. (spec. look up yours)
so say , i see closed loop failed, OBD2 scan page 1
i look at the O2 sensor an its stuck lean.
if stuck lean and it really is (o2 bad?) then its lean and it will surge
.
examples.
1: i find 02 sensor bad, (only effects idle and light steady cruise)
2: i find fuel pressure at 15PSI , hopeless low .
3: i find all injectors clogged. and lean.
4: with MAF EFI, ( i find maf reading too low, (dirty) causing lean.
5: if MAP car, i find the MAP stuck hard high vacuum causing lean.
not knowing what engine you have or the idle hot surge range,
i can not go farther.

the driving bog tells me,
1: scan the ecu ,get DTCs; do that first.
2: clean MAF if car has one, ask how..
3: check fuel pressure.


my guess is engine is lean. and starving for fuel all the time.
cept WOT.

MAF cars starve for fuel if there are any vacuum leaks.
MAP cars do opposite, they race fast with 100% full power.
MAF is air density EFI
MAP is speed density EFI.
apples and oranges diffr. so what engine.


1helpful
1answer

Increase then decrease idle when engine is cold especially

cold engine idle surge. (problem)
RPM range of surge not stated
300-700 or 800 to 1500? (range is critical to diagnosis)

bad fuel
running summer fuel in winter (running old fuel?)
needs a tune up bad, see the list in the operator guide.
idle speed controller,sticking or EGR valve same. (clean them)
location not stated, so cant guess about local air temps.?
no other symptoms, lack of engine power? etc?
was it ok last week, or better, when was the last time it was OK?
1week, 1year?
surge , causes, on a tuned engine might be:
1: too lean. so lean the ISC can not control idle. rpm low, stalling
2: too rich, flooding, stalling, spark plugs foul (look at them)
3: weak compression in 1 or more cylinders.
4: bad spark.
5: air leaks, in the plenum causing , ISC to lose control.
why high RPM?

especially?
well that means it fails hot too.
and there is a simple tests. for hot surge.
is engine fully hot? 180F and holds solid there?
say rpm is about 800
and you turn on head lights, heater fan and (not AC) and defrost.
the RPM must hold or the ISC is failing.
ISC -= idle speed controls. (all EFI has this function)
1helpful
1answer

How do you know if your spark plugs are the problem?

bad spark plug or bad wire will cause one cylinder not fire cause engine to surge.but change spark plugs and wires, if engine still surge have fuel filter changed, check fuel pressure weak fuel pump will cause engine surge.if you see check engine light flashing code scan for faulty TPS SENSOR OR FAULTY FUEL INJECTOR OR BAD IGNITION COIL.FAULT IN THE PCM.
0helpful
1answer

Truck surging

Surge usually means its getting extra air (VACUUM) from somewhere, usually a vacuum hose has come loose or developed a hole or crack letting extra air into the engine.
0helpful
1answer

I have a 1991 pontiac trans sport with a cold start engine surge. At cold start up the engine will increase and decrease in the rpm and sometime die but ofter the van worms up it seems to run ok.

remove and clean IAC ( idle air control ), this is what controls idling on to days cars. if this does not help a lot, check or replace coolant tempurature sensor. it may be bad, if it is, it will think the engine is always warm and send wrong info to pcm. good-day ! and may god bless. you can also have a vaccumn leak ! if check engine light is on, get it scanned to know what area is causing the problem.
0helpful
1answer

When I start my 1999 honda CRV it surges to about

no the surge that high is not normal a normal cold start should go to around 1500 then settle slowly to 750 or so but this all depends on engine temp and ambient air temperature
Not finding what you are looking for?

253 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Mini Experts

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

Thomas Perkins
Thomas Perkins

Level 3 Expert

15088 Answers

Sam Akber
Sam Akber

Level 3 Expert

1149 Answers

Are you a Mini Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...