Question about Canon PIXMA IP5200 InkJet Photo Printer

1 Answer

Printer says I have duplicate Magenta cartridges when I don't?

The yellow light flashes 15 times which in the manual says incompatible cartridges. I use all Canon Chromalife cartridges and always have. I've replaced the cartridge with a new one, but still get the same error message. What's up with this? My printer is 2 years old.

Thank you in advance for your help.

Kim Coleman

Posted by on

1 Answer

  • Level 1:

    An expert who has achieved level 1.

  • Contributor
  • 2 Answers
Re: Printer says I have duplicate Magenta cartridges when...

I think it's the chips on the cartridge - the colour that it thinks it's duplicating! I took it off the black (duplicated) and put it on the magenta and it thought it had duplicate magenta cartridges!!

Posted on Feb 01, 2008

Add Your Answer

0 characters

Uploading: 0%


Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add


3 Points

Related Questions:

1 Answer

Installed new ink cartridges but yellow light keeps flashing. Also on Magenta and Yellow, there is an X on the cartridge. I have tried several times, turning off the machine, inserting the cartridges,...

most probably your ink cartridge is faulty.
There is a user guide in the CD when you purchase the printer. You can refer to that or you can download the user guide here...
just search for you model and you will be able to located the softcopy.

Jan 19, 2011 | Epson Stylus Multifunction Inkjet Printer/...

1 Answer

HP Business Ink jet 1200. Yellow cartridge lite is on. Changed cartridge, but lite is still on,

Ink cartridge lights: Black, Blue, Magenta, Yellow

When light is on - ink is low (below 25%)
When light is flashing - out of ink - printer stops - replace cartridge

To get a printer status / configuration report press the info button (to the left of the on button)

Oct 07, 2010 | HP Inkjet 1200dn Printer

1 Answer

I have a hp 2600n printer. I have just replaced the black print cartridge because the yellow light was flashing and asking me to reorder supplies. Now the yellow light is still flashing the frist box if...

“All lights blinking and printer not responding” is indicative of serious ink cartridge issue. Usually when this happens the printer fails to goes through the motions of the printing process, kind of stands still with indicator lights just blinking away. This could be as a result of either of these scenarios.
i.                     Ink cartridge has developed incompatibility or is incompatible
The Solution is to try an older/another cartridge (doesn’t matter if ink is finished. You must replace cartridge one at a time). If lights stop blinking it confirms that your cartridge has become incompatible or developed incompatibility. Also if your printer is the type that can work with only one cartridge, remove one after the other (closing back the lid/cover) to determine which in the set (black or color) has become incompatible. At the instance the incompatible one is removed and you close the lid, the blinking will stop (for printers that can print with one ink cartridge only). Just replace the incompatible one and start printing again. In most cases the issue is always with one cartridge. But if both are affected, you have to replace both. Because of this type of problem, always keep used cartridges somewhere safe; they come in handy for this type of troubleshooting.
ii.                   The Cartridge electronic panel  is dirty
The electronic panel on the cartridge that makes contact with the cartridge carrier inside the printer is dirty and needs cleaning.  This electronic panel is front part of the cartridge with copper “dots”.
The Solution is to try to clean this panel with a piece of folded tissue paper soaked in a bit of methylated spirit. Also try to clean the area in the cartridge carrier/holder that makes contact with the cartridge’s electronic panel (Usually this is more difficult). If you cannot reach it with your fingers, use a stick or something with tissue wrapped around it. Allow to dry well and return the cartridges, close the cover. The blinking should stop if the electronic panel is the issue. Once the blinking stops the printer will print.

Mar 24, 2010 | HP Color LaserJet 2600n Printer

2 Answers

Canon Pixma yellow color problem

Either the ink you are using is not going to give the color you want, or you have print heads that are blocked.

Mar 11, 2010 | Canon PIXMA iP4200 InkJet Photo Printer

1 Answer

Canon MP610 Printer

You cannot switch to the larger black cartridge. You are using a CMYK (Cyan, Yellow, Magenta, Black) format for printing color images.

The larger cartridge is used for text only. The smaller black cartridge is used for color or graphic images.

If the black cartridge was not present, every time you needed black in an image, it would have to come from the composition of Cyan, Magenta and Yellow. This would greatly reduce the life of the color cartridges.


Dec 12, 2009 | Canon PIXMA MP610 InkJet Printer

1 Answer

Photosmart C5280. Instructions on photo cartridge 348 say remove both black and colour cartridges, then install photo cartridge in right hand cartridge holder. Printer screen then tells me to install...

Your printer uses the following cartridges:

HP 74 - Black ink
HP 75 - Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow ink
HP 99 - Photo Black, Light Cyan, and Light Magenta

You need Photo Black, Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, Light Cyan, and Light Magenta to print photos. To accomplish this you install the HP 99 photo cartridge where your HP 74 black cartridge usually goes and you keep the HP 75 color cartridge where it's at. I don't know why your printer told you to remove both cartridges, then reinstall the HP 75 color cartridge.

Oct 10, 2009 | HP Photosmart C5280 InkJet Printer

2 Answers

Printer won't recognize the new ink cartridge

Each cartridge has a electronic chip pre-porogrammed at the factory.
If it is a reputable store they will exchange for the right color as they can return the PM to Canon as defective,

Mar 27, 2009 | Canon PIXMA iP4300 InkJet Photo Printer

1 Answer

Flashing Red Lights

it means that some time you are using low quality ink
or the paper not loaded correctly
thank you

Jan 11, 2008 | Epson Stylus C84 InkJet Printer

1 Answer

Printer does not print

An ink supplier advised turning off the printer for 15 minutes, turn it on and try again. That worked once. Next time he suggested turning off printer, removing all cartridges, waiting 15 minutes, replacing cartridges. I couldn't do this without turning the printer back on and going through the replace cartridges routine. Now the nozzle check routine printed magenta and yellow only. I've run the head cleaner a number of times with no success.  Hope one of these suggestions works for you. 

Jan 06, 2008 | Epson Stylus C84 InkJet Printer

1 Answer

Minolta CMS magicolor printer 2300W

there should be a light flashing on the printer. try pressing the button nearest to it to see if that will move the print head out in order that you can replace the cartridge

Jul 18, 2007 | HP Printer Cartridges (Complete List): ,...

Not finding what you are looking for?
Canon PIXMA IP5200 InkJet Photo Printer Logo

99 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Canon Printers & Copiers Experts


Level 3 Expert

93802 Answers

old marine
old marine

Level 3 Expert

1294 Answers

Donald DCruz
Donald DCruz

Level 3 Expert

17129 Answers

Are you a Canon Printer and Copier Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides