Not sure if this is the same as you have but my printer always prints out the first page, lifts up...
(More)
Not sure if this is the same as you have but my printer always prints out the first page, lifts up the second sheet out of a tray, and that is it. More details, pls see http://annoyances-resolved.blogspot.com/2009/10/recurring-laser-printer-paper-jam.html