Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus Silver Edition Graphic Calculator
Problem for Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus Silver Edition Graphic...

When I put X^(1/3) into Y=, and go to nDeriv, and




By twistinggato on Nov 10, 2009

" "
When I put X^(1/3) into Y=, and go to nDeriv, and find the derivative at X=0, the calculator gives me 100. I (and a few math teachers) have done this many times by hand, and we all get undefined as an answer. Why is the calculator getting the wrong answer?

Best Solution

posted on Nov 10, 2009
Very Helpful)

k24674

Rank: Guru  Office Equipment  Expert
Rating: 87%, 681 votes
Hello,
The derivative of the cubic root of x is, as you wll know, equal to (1/3)*x^(-2/3). Its limit as x approaches 0 is undefined. However the calculator uses approximate representations of numbers to calculate. And you can never be sure what it is going to give as results near singularities (poles of functions).

Calculators with Computer Algebra Systems can do better. To show you this, I am enclosing a screen capture showing you the correct result.

On this screen I defined a function u =f(v) where u is the derivative of cubic root of v. I stored 0 in the dummy variable v, and I evaluated the function u at v=0. You can see that the result displayed is undefined.
That this result is deemed correct seems to me just a matter of convention. We do not know, we cannot know, or we dont care to know? It will not make any of us lose sleep.

Hope it helps.

Comments:

Nov 10, 2009

- OOPS!! On first line should be: as you well know
Was this helpful?
Yes
No
1 person thought this was helpful

Popular Solutions for Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus


Questions and Unsolved Problems for Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus


Do you recommend Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus Silver Edition Graphic Calculator?
Answer

Answer
my gc can't work at all, after i tried to install some necessary applications. where can i get it... (More)

Answer
The Line( command on my TI-84+SE calculator does not erase even though I have the synrtax correct.

Answer
how can you change your language on your ti 84 silver edition calculator in under 4 key strokes

Answer
says, RAM cleared and is not responding to any commands entered. what is wrong?

Answer
my second row of buttons dont work. 4 5 6 subtract. evreything else does


Didn't find what you were looking for?

Describe your problem:

Select a Category:







Ask our Experts

 

Solve Your Problem Now!
Chat Live with an Expert
Chat Now
Browse popular Problems
More Common Problems
Most Common Problems for:
For Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus...:

Top Calculator Experts

Rank: Guru Guru  

Solutions: 769
Member Since: September 2009

Experience: More than 5 years attempt with printers, computers and all office equipment

Ask Me
Find more Calculator Experts

Top Copier & Fax Repair

(800) 816-6855
Over 50 years in the office equipment repair &...
EBS Scantracker

(877) 434-9747
Full service mobile shredder repair service to...
Pacific Coast Shredder Repair


       
Solve Your Problem Now!
Chat Live with an Expert
Chat Now

X
Continue
When the original poster rates a solution that was given to his own problem, that rating is locked!
X

Are you sure the solution content is Inappropriate?
   
Tech buddies can communicate directly to answer questions. Become a Tech Buddy and have direct access to your favorite expert for FREE!
Insert Link
Insert Image
Insert You-Tube clip
Insert List
Insert List
Spell Check

What is this?



Select