When I put X^(1/3) into Y=, and go to nDeriv, and find the derivative at X=0, the calculator gives me 100. I (and a few math teachers) have done this many times by hand, and we all get undefined as an answer. Why is the calculator getting the wrong answer?
Hello, The derivative of the cubic root of x is, as you wll know, equal to (1/3)*x^(-2/3). Its limit as x approaches 0 is undefined. However the calculator uses approximate representations of numbers to calculate. And you can never be sure what it is going to give as results near singularities (poles of functions).
Calculators with Computer Algebra Systems can do better. To show you this, I am enclosing a screen capture showing you the correct result. On this screen I defined a function u =f(v) where u is the derivative of cubic root of v. I stored 0 in the dummy variable v, and I evaluated the function u at v=0. You can see that the result displayed is undefined. That this result is deemed correct seems to me just a matter of convention. We do not know, we cannot know, or we dont care to know? It will not make any of us lose sleep.
Hope it helps.
Comments:
Nov 10, 2009
- OOPS!! On first line should be: as you well know
Was this helpful?
Yes
No
1 person thought this was helpful
Popular Solutions for Texas Instruments TI-84 Plus
my gc can't work at all, after i tried to install some necessary applications. where can i get it...
(More)
my gc can't work at all, after i tried to install some necessary applications. where can i get it fixed?