Question about Heating & Cooling

2 Answers

Do electric resistance heating devices loose efficiency w/ age?

I am working with a condominium HOA that is proposing to replace 6 25KW electric unit heaters in their common garage in hopes of reducing their electrical consumption. I am trying to find out whether electric resistance heaters loose efficiency with age. It is my understanding that electric resistance heating elements are theoretically 100% efficient - i.e. 1 KWH of electricity consumed by an electrical resistance heater will ALWAYS produce 3412.3 BTU of heat.

I am aware that some resistance heating elements will produce less heat as they age but I assume they also consume less electricity as their output drops. I also am aware that other factors may affect the EFFECTIVE efficiency of an electric resistance heater such as controls, fans, placement, buildup of lint, etc. I am really only trying to verify what I believe to be the fundamental physics of the issue - that a new electric heater will not inherently be less costly to operate per rate KWH.

I have advised the HOA they should not expect their energy cost to to down as a result of their simply replacing old wall mounted electric unit heaters with new electric heaters of the same output. I am looking for some backup that my advise is sound.

Thanks!

Posted by on

  • 1 more comment 
  • shopper355 Jul 20, 2009

    This did not answer my question - whether electric resistance heaters loose efficiency (fewer BTU per KWH consumed) over time.

  • shopper355 Jul 20, 2009

    So you agree that basic physics dictates that 1 KWH of electricity consumed by an electrical resistance heater will ALWAYS produce 3412.3 BTU of heat (i.e. there is no other way for the electricity to be consumed)?

  • shopper355 Jul 20, 2009

    Yes, the response was helpful!

×

Ad

2 Answers

  • Level 3:

    An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

    Superstar:

    An expert that got 20 achievements.

    All-Star:

    An expert that got 10 achievements.

    MVP:

    An expert that got 5 achievements.

  • Master
  • 3,037 Answers

Overall Natural Gas would be best but generally the efficiency in electric resistance heaters is not really lost (very minimum) as long as they are kept clean, aren't falling apart, and proper airflow is kept which it seems you are already aware of. All electric resistance heaters are considered 100 percent efficient because there is no heat loss through ducts or combustion. Remember that some space heaters deliver heat more quickly or more concentrated than others. Also again, using electric resistant heat to heat the entire house is generally more expensive than using other systems like a natural gas furnace or a heat pump.

So overall, it will probably not be any cheaper to operate the new systems to the old ones but if the old units are wearing down and falling apart, maybe it is time to replace. I hope this helps.


Benjamin

Posted on Jul 20, 2009

  • Benjamin Patri
    Benjamin Patri Jul 20, 2009

    yes, I agree with that statement. It may not be dissipated as well in the future but it should still produce the same as long as it is kept up.

×

Ad
  • Level 3:

    An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

    All-Star:

    An expert that got 10 achievements.

    MVP:

    An expert that got 5 achievements.

    Vice President:

    An expert whose answer got voted for 100 times.

  • Master
  • 601 Answers

Hi...

Don't know how much this will help. I agree with that replacing the heater will not do much help in the consumption of electricity, but it should be use in a much optimum way. The operation of electric resistance heaters to heat an area for a long period of time is generally considered to be costly. However intermittent or partial day use can be more cost efficient than whole building heating since there savings due to superior zonal control.
Example: A lunch room in an office setting has limited hours of operation. During low use periods a "monitor" level of heat (50 °F/10 °C) is provided by the central heating system. Peak use times between the hours of 11:00–14:00 are heated to "comfort levels" (70 °F/21 °C). Significant savings can be realized in overall energy consumption since infrared radiation losses through thermal conductivity are not as large with a smaller temperature gradient both between this space and unheated outside air as well as between the refrigerator and the (now cooler) lunch room.
Economically, electric heat is very efficient, and can be compared to other sources of home heating by calculating the cost per kilowatt hour multiplied by the efficiency of the heater, and then multiplied by the number of kilowatts the heater uses.
Thanks
Smith

Posted on Jul 20, 2009

Ad

1 Suggested Answer

6ya6ya
  • 2 Answers

SOURCE: I have freestanding Series 8 dishwasher. Lately during the filling cycle water hammer is occurring. How can this be resolved

Hi,
a 6ya expert can help you resolve that issue over the phone in a minute or two.
Best thing about this new service is that you are never placed on hold and get to talk to real repairmen in the US.
the service is completely free and covers almost anything you can think of.(from cars to computers, handyman, and even drones)
click here to download the app (for users in the US for now) and get all the help you need.
Goodluck!

Posted on Jan 02, 2017

Add Your Answer

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

1 Answer

When it is 20 degrees or less my heetpump outside unit hums high & low pulses is this normal, temp. is fine.


Heat pumps don't work when the temperature is at 20F. They run the best at about 40-50F. At 20F, the compressor doesn't come on and it switches to electric resistance heating. So you pay full price for your heat when it is that cold. The hum you hear is caused by the temperature sensor deciding whether to run the compressor or run the resistance heat. Twenty F is pretty much the cut off point where the heat pump loses it's fabled 300% efficiency (which actually happens at around 50F) At 20F the heat pump is very close to 100% efficient , so it makes no sense to get the wear and tear on the mechanics of the unit, so it switches to resistance heat which is also at 100% efficiency with no moving parts.

Feb 26, 2015 | Heating & Cooling

3 Answers

Heat pump is not kicking in no heat at 42 degree outdoor temp


check the wirings.the coils and also the heating element.also check the heating temprature.
also check the power outlet.
connect some where else.
and try to restart it again after five minites.after you unplug the device from the electric outlet.

Oct 10, 2008 | Amana PTH123B35AE Air Conditioner

Tip

Gas and Electric Dryer Troubleshooting & Repair.


The following procedures will help you repair your dryer whether it is gas or electric. While doing any resistance checks on the unit make sure it is unplugged as you will be exposed to lethal voltages if the unit is not dieconnected. Additionally when doing resistance checks remove one wire of the circuit, replace the wire when done. The best place to get parts for any appliance, best price and availability, is at http://www.repairclinic.com .

Electric dryers are probably the most common so I will address that first. If the unit spins we know it has power. Move to the next paragraph. If it doesn't spin check the receptacle for 120 vac. If you have it. check the door switch for continuity. Remove the top to access the switch. Using a DMM, on resistance scale, depress the switch and see that it has no resistance. If this checks bad (high resistance) replace it. If good access the start switch. This may require removing the control panel from the top of the unit. While engaging the start switch check for continuity. If open, replace it.

The most likely culprit, when the unit spins but does not heat, on an electric unit, is the heating element. Once used they get brittle and any moving around can crack them. With the unit unplugged remove the back. Should only be several screws around the perimeter. Some units have an inspection plate which can be removed to access the element. Using a DMM on resistance, check the continuity of the coil. It should read several ohms if good. If it reads infinity, you need a new heating element.

If the coil checks OK you will need to check the limit switch. It is located somewhere in the vent area and shuts the unit down if it overheats. Many times these bimetal switches stick open. It looks like a hocky puck mounted to the vent. Once located remove at least one wire and check for continuity. It should have no resistance. If it has a high resistance it will need to be replaced. This should solve your problems if you have an electric dryer. Either the heating element, door switch, start switch or the limit switch will be bad.

If you have a gas dryer the resistive coil is replaced by a gas burner which is a little more difficult, and dangerous, to troubleshoot. If it is less than ten years old it should have electric start. Open the inspection door on the bottom front and see that when you call for drying, (start it), the igniter sparks. If it doesn't and it obviously has power the igniter box will need to be replaced.

If the igniter works and you know that you have gas (other gas appliances work) and the gas valve on the dryer is on, then the control valve has a problem and will need replaced. This may be a job for a professional as working with gas is dangerous and you should be qualified to do the repair.

Beyond those two items there is a light sensor in case the flame doesn't start or goes out. This shuts the gas valve but would only be a factor in the repair if the units burner lights up, runs for a minute and shuts down. It is a photo cell located in the area of the burner.

There is also a tempreture sensor but this would only be a factor if the unit heats but not to operating level. It is similar to the limit switch on an electric dryer and the same troubleshooting applies.

With the above information you should be able to repair any dryer on the planet. Good luck.

Thanks for using FixYa

hardrocko

on Aug 03, 2010 | Dryers

Tip

Home Electric Heat Heating and Electric


Electric heat can come in many different forms. Some of these methods are resistance heating, electric arc heating, induction heating, and dielectric heating. The most common of these is the resistance heating. With the resistance heating of electric baseboard heating, water heating and kitchen ranges, you don't have to worry about carbon monoxide or unvented gases. However, direct with electric is really not considered ecologically sound because most electricity uses fossil fuels. This is because about two-thirds of the energy of the fuel is lost within the power stations, and in transmission line losses.

Some of the most popular choices for electric heating systems are thermal storage systems, electric radiant heating, hydronic electric heating and even convective heating. You can also install an off-peak system that can save money and also give you the convenience of electric heat. An example of an off-peak electric heating system that is very common today is an electric plenum heater. Another newer form of heating is a convective electric heating system. Both use electric heaters to heat the air that is then circulated with blowers throughout your home.

Electric heating has several unique advantages. It can be precisely controlled to allow a uniformity of temperature within very narrow limits, it is cleaner than many other methods of heating. It does not involve any combustion and it is considered very safe because it is protected from overloading by automatic breakers. It is quick to use easy to adjust and it is relatively quiet. The main disadvantages of electric heating in industry are the higher cost of electrical energy compared to direct use of fuel, and the capital cost of both the electric heating unit itself and the electrical wiring required to deliver large quantities of electrical energy to the point of use.
Electric heat does have a place. One place where it does shine is in a seasonal cottage that will only be used a few times a year. It is very easy to shut down the heat and turn it back on when you get back there. There is also very little that can go wrong or go bad from the long periods of non-use. For this situation electric is a very good choice. This is really the only situation in which I recommend electric heating.

As you can easily see, electric heating has some advantages and some disadvantages. The cost of electricity has continued to rise and will be skyrocketing even higher in the future. Many states have or will be deregulated electric or are going to do so in the very near future. With the future uncertainty of the cost of electric and the great amount of waste in the transmission system of electric, many owners of electric heating systems are debating whether or not to convert to hydronic baseboard heating. With the super high efficiency of today's gas and oil boilers, they are quickly becoming much more attractive to many homeowners. Combining a high efficiency gas or oil boiler with hot water baseboard or radiant heating gives you great comfort and will give you low utility costs for many years to come.

on Dec 25, 2009 | Heating & Cooling

1 Answer

My chauffe air heater will not give off any heat


see this causes and fix it. God bless you
If an appliance that should produce heat does not, inspect the element for breaks or obvious damage. If you don't see any damage, test the element for continuity (see below).
  1. Turn off power to the appliance or device. If the unit is plugged in, unplug it from the electrical receptacle (outlet); if the device is wired into the circuit (such as an oven), turn off the circuit at the electrical service panel.
  2. Disassemble the appliance or device to access the heating element, following the guides in this book for your appliance. Some heating elements, such as plug-in units in electric ovens, are relatively easy to remove (see the Electric Oven Fix-It Guide).
  3. Set the multimeter to RX1 (resistance times 1).
  4. Touch the multimeter probes to each end of the element.
  5. High resistance (kilo-ohms or thousands of ohms) indicates the heating element is okay. A reading of infinite resistance indicates a broken element.
  6. If a heating element is faulty, replace it with one of the exact size, shape, power rating, and resistance.
  7. Reassemble the appliance or device and turn it on or plug it in to test it.

Oct 01, 2012 | Leisure HOMEPRIDE Electric Fireplace...

1 Answer

WHAT IS RESISTANCE WELDING?


Electric resistance welding (ERW) refers to a group of welding processes such as spot and seam welding that produce coalescence of faying surfaces where heat to form the weld is generated by the electical reistance of material vs the time and the force used to hold the materials together during welding. Some factors influencing heat or welding temperatures are the proportions of the workpieces, the coating or the lack of coating, the electrode materials, electrode geometry, electrode pressing force, weld current and weld time. Small pools of molten metal are formed at the point of most electrical resistance (the connecting surfaces) as a high current (100-100,000 A) is passed through the metal. In general, resistance welding methods are efficient and cause little pollution, but their applications are limited to relatively thin materials and the equipment cost can be high. although in production situations the cost per weld may be as low as $.04 usd per weld depending on application and manufacturing rate.

Feb 02, 2011 | Computers & Internet

1 Answer

My heat pump has a problem heating when it is very cold. should i cut the emerg. heat on?


The emergency heat setting on the heat pump thermostat is manually selected by the equipment owner. This is usually in response to a malfunction in the outdoor unit. Doing so locks out the outdoor unit. The indoor auxiliary heating system must provide the heat required. Setting the thermostat to the heat position allows the outdoor unit to operate. Due to the expense of electric resistance heating compared to the efficiency of the heat pump, repairs should be made as soon as possible.
MORE HERE

Dec 15, 2010 | Heating & Cooling

1 Answer

I have a intertherm mobile home furnace. When i turn on the heat the circuit breaker in the funace heats up and blows the breaker. this only happens when i turn on the heat if i turn on the fan it is...


you said it yourself. when an electrical device is running it produces amps, with every amp is a unit of heat. breakers are heat sensitive as well. so you might want to consider a new breaker. newer breakers are made out of better materials that are able to displace heat more efficiently. or check to make sure the screws on the terminals where the wires go in are tight. if there is a loose connection that will increase the units of heat traveling through the termination. or, worse case scenario, like when all hope is lost. splice in some more wire, correctly, emphasis on correctly, and relocate the breaker. perhaps use insulation around the breaker, non flammable of course.

Nov 11, 2010 | Electric Electrical Supplies

1 Answer

The clean light keeps blinking and won't run new cycle


Whirlpool & Kitchen-Aid
Tall Tub Dishwashers
PROBLEM: STOPPED RUNNING, WILL NOT START AND CLEAN LED BLINKS 7 TIMES, THEN REPEATS (WATER HEATING FAULT)
Control is programmed to stop running and not allow any further
cycles if it detects a water heating problem (no temperature
increase detected in heated Main Wash cycle or in 3 consecutive
cycles on the latest software version). Control blinks the Clean
LED 7 times repeatedly and disables the Start/Resume key until
cleared.
Running Diagnostics clears the control and allows it
to operate again. The water heating condition
must be corrected or the control will stop
running again. See potential causes below.
Check If…
Heater circuit problem:
♦ Open heater.
♦ Wire disconnected, open connection or component
in heater circuit.
♦ Faulty heater drive circuit on control.
Then…
1. Check operation of heater in Diagnostics cycle.
2. Unplug dishwasher or disconnect power.
3. Check resistance of heater and all components
and connections in the water heating circuit or heat
dry circuit.
Door switch not making contact consistently:
♦ Misaligned door latch assembly (which can be
aggravated by high door closure force keeping
strike plate from fully seating).
♦ Faulty door switch (high resistance).
♦ Loose or missing installation anchor screws,
causing tank to shift in cut-out.
NOTE: Neutral switch on plastic tub models is only in series with
the heater; other loads are not affected.
1. Unplug dishwasher or disconnect power.
2. Measure resistance of door switch contacts while
checking mechanical operation of latch assembly.
Confirm switches not loose from assembly. Check
strike plate and door closure.
Wash pump not pumping water past the heater efficiently.
• Foreign object in pump
• Excessive foaming
• Clogged pump screen or broken chopper screen
• Loose electrical connection in motor circuit
See Tech Sheet “WASH PUMP WILL NOT PUMP”.
Lack of water to heat. (Unit not filling properly)
• Insufficient water supply pressure
• Fill valve screen blocked or valve not opening fully
• Loose electrical connection on Fill Valve.
• Float switch obstructed or functioning abnormally
See Tech Sheet “WILL NOT FILL OR LOW
WATER”.
Diagnostic Key Dance:
Heat Dry - Normal - Heat Dry - Normal or
High Temp - Air Dry - High Temp - Air Dry

HOPE THIS HELP

Jan 24, 2010 | KitchenAid 24 in. KUDS01FLSS Built-In...

1 Answer

When I touch the aluminum heat transfer fins on my home A/C unit, they turn to power. I understand the different metal problems (copper/aluminum) with electrolysis, but what activates this problem. Are...


Your right, it will lose efficiency. Acid rain causes this and with the right chemical fumes around your unit, it can cause it. There are no anodes that will help. Time to replace the coils or the whole system.

Mar 31, 2009 | Heating & Cooling

Not finding what you are looking for?
Heating & Cooling Logo

Related Topics:

92 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Heating & Cooling Experts

Paul Carew

Level 3 Expert

2557 Answers

Dan Webster
Dan Webster

Level 3 Expert

8220 Answers

Donni Steen

Level 3 Expert

659 Answers

Are you a Heating and Cooling Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...