Important information needed: 1. What is the max load at one time.? 2. How close will the max load be from support.. ie the max point load sitting on an intermediate support is different than sitting between supports... 3. What is the expected lifespan of the bridge? 4. Are there life safety issues? ie is it a step off for actors or a horrifying plummet... 5. What kind of truss construction are you considering.. incorrectly built truss is deceptive, its not as strong as you think
A 32 foot wooden span is tricky enough that I would advise strongly advise consulting an engineer, our theatre has a friendly engineer who advises us out of a love of theatre (and tix).
In article <389777CA.4B620 @bellsouth.net>, x @bellsouth.net
Certainly be interested to see that, Chris, if you got a moment to do it.
Yes, I realise that. But (at least as far as I know) walls built from studding and drywall - which I think is the same as the stuff we call plasterboard here in the UK - aren't normally load bearing, they are just partitions.
What was going through my mind was that you can put an actual figure on the theoretical load bearing capability of a timber built structure whereas I don't know whether you could with a metal stud built structure.
I appreciate that we rarely actually do a calculation like that because we know what the right size timber is for a particular job. But we only know that because someone somewhere has done the calculation and the resulting knowledge has been handed on through training course, books, on the job training etc. etc.
Not a problem with a flat, where the idea sounds very interesting indeed, but more difficult with, say, a platform or the bridge structure which I think you were talking about. Obviously you are happy with the idea and I was really just wondering whether you had any scientific basis for that or whether it was the empirical "well we've done it and it was perfectly rigid and didn't show any signs of breaking".
Andy
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #2
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Mini Me - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Regarding the thread about the span itself it turns out that Georgia Pacific and others make wood I joists capable of spanning 34' and more, with a 16" joist 12" o.c.
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #4
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Janice - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
I've done 16' spans before using microlam beams.
If memory serves the last one was a 16' span using three beams that were 9" deep for a bridge 3 or 4 feet wide.
A building supply (a real lumber yard, not home depot) will usually have a salesman who can help you size the beams. There is typically a bit of lead time involved because most yards don't stock microlam.
Just another thought...
David Boevers Commercial Theatre Project Manager/Project Engineer Las Vegas, NV
Address is filtered, remove "SPAMBLOK" to reply
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #5
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Gary10 - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
I believe microlam and paralam are both brand names, and gluelam is more vague. I really am not versed in all the different brands.
What I did discover is that some of the laminated beams are meant for use as cap plates for foundations and are not span rated at all. So my one piece of advice would be to be sure you're looking at a span rated material. The supplier shuold be able to provide you with the manufaturer's span tables. These will show required depth and spacing for a given span and live load.
The cost is obviously higher than traditional lumber, and you may have to absorb some shipping expenses, but against the labor of fabricating a truss it doesn't look so expensive.
Like I said in my last post, I seem o remember using 1.75" wide, 9" deep microlam on 18" centers to span 16 feet. I doubt any TGI or TJI joist would make the span. But I've been wrong before - check the span tables...
David Boevers Commercial Theatre Project Manager/Project Engineer Las Vegas, NV
Address is filtered, remove "SPAMBLOK" to reply
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #6
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Bray - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Is microlam the equivalent of Gluelam/paralam or is it a more traditional engineered lumber? Any idea on cost? How is it to work with? I wonder if the mdf engineered joists would be adequate for a 16 foot span?
<20000201160012.28820.00000 @ng-fw1.aol.com>...
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #7
posted on Aug 09, 2005
man1 - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
We use 1/4 inch lauan for hard flats, attached with #6 sheet metal screws. According to an article in USITT, the folks who came up with this method attached canvas by wrapping it around the back and using drywall screws every six inches. We cover the lauan with muslin. But we're covering a set of flats for the next show driectly with duveteyne, so I'll let youknow if that actually works - I think the cloth will get twisted up around the screw, myself.
We use the studs for cross-bracing, and no corner bracing is needed. I've been meaning to scan the photos, as someone else requested pix a few months ago. I'll try to dig them up.
We wear gloves during fabrication, then duct tape over any bits that may be contacted during performance. But all the sharp edges are pointing towards the inside of the unit.
Well, the 1-5/8" stud is just to hold up drywall. But they build houses out of the stuff, so steel stud in general is up to most tasks.
-- {:-( Dionysian Reveler
We all agree that your theory is crazy, but is it crazy enough? Niels Bohr (1885-1962) (to Wolfgang Pauli)
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #8
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Pasty - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
In article <38962884.73EC @bellsouth.net>, x @bellsouth.net
Hm, that's an interesting idea.
How do you attach the covering of the flat and make up the corners/cross bracing?
Also the stuff sold in the UK as metal studding has quite sharp edges as I recall. Is the US stuff different/do you just live with it/do you have some way around it?
I would see a problem about using it for anything that supported load in the sense that I don't think such studding has any kind of stress rating - or does it?
Andy
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #10
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Rogers - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
In article <uw7l4.14074 $nh2.247 @cac1.rdr.news.psi.ca>, "Matthew R. Bates" <mat @istar.ca> wrote: 500lbs (2 actors plus 3/4 inch plywood support.. ie the max point load than sitting between height
considering.. incorrectly built think-- 2 x 12 span supported underneath with a 2 x 4 truss- so the truss would really just be supporting the 2 x 12-
Forget the 32 foot span- think this would work for 16 foot span? would advise strongly advise friendly engineer who advises us 32 foot span or 2 16 foot
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #12
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Brad - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
We get ours from a building supply company - we get a discount no that we've opened an account with them. Home Depot carries a limited stock of steel stud.
Don't have a price off hand (I don't order material, so I'll have to ask) but the costs are generally 20% - 60% less than a similar amount of wood, depending on the specific material.
For example, we now use 1 1/8 25 ga stud for framing flats. We can get a bundle of ten @10' sticks for $14. Compare to 100 feet of 1x3, then realize that there is no wastage due to knots, warps or other imperfections. And it doesn't weigh anything - the whole bundle weighs less than ten pounds.
A final note - I had the gauge wrong - we'll be using either 18ga or 16 ga on our structure. We just got the drawings in, so we'll know more tomorrow.
-- {:-( Dionysian Reveler
We all agree that your theory is crazy, but is it crazy enough? Niels Bohr (1885-1962) (to Wolfgang Pauli)
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #13
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Cato - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
A sixteen foot span is quite a gap, considering most nominal dimension lumber uses 4 to 8 foot spans... Can you consider any of the following (this being theatre and all) -build it out of steel and dress it to look like timber, then you could make decorative truss out of 1/4 or ply, enourmous weight savings, and dollar savings, you could probably recover some money from the steel - hide a intermediate support a) through the upstage curtain (think of the magician levitating lady gag) or through the floor, a semi hidden pipe coming up from the trap room idea. -can you hang the structure from the ceiling with wire rope, get some advice from an expert, but black sheathed wire rope is very low visibility.
Remember if you build a bridge that looks nice the director is guaranteed to put the whole cast on it.... unless its a two hander don't count on designing it for 500 pounds.... Don't forget to prevent access during construction on stage either, people love to come explore and if its not done, they love to fall off and through, stairs and bridges are death traps until finished...
If your'e determined to build a timber structure, if you have time, consider calling a local university and maybe getting the civil engineering dept to use it as design problem....? something that happened to me in univ...
Enjoy, hope this helps Matthew B
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on span solution:
Solution #14
posted on Aug 09, 2005
Reynolds - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
I would not consider building such a structure with 2x4 in any arrangement.
We're building a 34 foot span in two sections - we're using 8"x 20 ga steel stud, assembled as i-beams, on two foot centers. Each half will be at a slight incline, meeting in the middle (we're waiting on drawings from the designer, but should start on working drawings tomorrow).
The advantage to steel stud construction is that you get the strength of steel, but do not need welding equipment or abrasive saws. It's also inexpensive. And much, much lighter.
-- {:-( Dionysian Reveler
We all agree that your theory is crazy, but is it crazy enough? Niels Bohr (1885-1962) (to Wolfgang Pauli)
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it: