Technical Support, Instructions & Repair Service

Back to: 

Tags:

Garmin Edge 305 GPS Receiver

Can standard components do rough distance...


By Bomber - usenet poster


I'm wondering whether it's possible to do rough distance measurement
by interrogating a remote device via RF and measuring the amount of
time it takes to reply (subtracting the known processing time, delay
to transmit a full packet of X bytes at Y bps) using a standard RF
module and microcontroller.

In theory the unknown period less known delays, then divided by 2
should be the time it's taken for the signal to travel one way.

If the speed of light is 299,792,458 metres per second then to measure
to a resolution of (say) ~300m would require a measuring precision of
1 microsecond, or a frequency of 1MHz if it was a free running
counter; 100ns / 10MHz for 30m resolution and 10ns / 100MHz for 3m
resolution.

A 100MHz microcontroller clock speed sounds impractical, but perhaps a
compromise could be using a dedicated high speed counter that the
microcontroller can read.

2am ramblings so apologies if I'm barking up the wrong tree. Thanks
for any assistance.
I have the same problem Post a new problem
This Problem has been added to the Share Your Expertise Page under "My Work Queue".

Solution #1

posted on Aug 18, 2008
Not Rated (0)

Guest

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Edge 305 turn off at every little bump.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Solution #2

posted on Aug 01, 2007
Not Rated (0)

LiZzIe

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Forget it, you'll be wasting your time trying to turn this into a
practical working system. The devil will be in the detail, and you'll
never get it working anywhere near the accuracy of your GPS (even when
it "plays up").
Get a second GPS if you really are that worried about having a backup,
perhaps one with a different antenna system (like Helical and a SiRF
chipset). Or simply get one with an external antenna connection and
attach a better antenna onto your pack or whatever.

But like I said, learn to use your GPS properly and you'll be able to
ignore those occasional "80m jump" errors. And when you get back and
upload your track log you can simply remove those points from your
track log manually because they are really obvious. I use my (bottom
of the range patch antenna) GPS for tracking inside canyons and deep
gullies and I still am able to get very usable track logs by removing
only a couple of bogus data points. So in practice it's a trivial
problem you are trying to solve here.

Dave.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Solution #3

posted on Aug 01, 2007
Not Rated (0)

Powe33

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
The "receiver" (they're really transceivers) will be mounted on my
car, so it should be able to track correctly from the moment I move
away. Here's how it would work:

- car sends TX packet, noting the point at which the very last bit was
completed
- mobile device receives complete packet, then resends it
- car receives TX packet noting the point at which the very last bit
was received, then deducts known delay to calculate effective round
trip time.

Another idea I had was for the mobile device to receive on one
frequency and transmit on another, which literally repeats a stream of
data that the car mounted transceiver can use to calculate distance
(averaged on a per bit basis, rather than per packet). This would not
require any fancy counting of MPU cycles in order to figure out the
software delay between receiving a ping packet and retransmitting it.

As I said earlier, supplementary data for sanity checking of the GPS
output, and a rough backup for when GPS isn't functional. I should
make it clear that I want to track where I've *been* - once I get home
- not where I'm going.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Solution #4

posted on Aug 01, 2007
Not Rated (0)

Grant

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
How on earth do you plan to use this while walking or doing any other
activity?
You need a transmitter and the receiver. Plan to walk 10km, place your
receiver, walk back, and then start your walk again?
The "backup" for a GPS is a map and compass, and with proper compass/
topo navigation techniques it is possible to get the accuracy you
require.

Learning how to use your GPS and knowing when to believe it is
important. Trail logs allow you to see if it's telling you the truth
or not, and there are lots of tricks for getting better accuracy under
marginal conditions.

Care to explain exactly what it is you are trying to achieve here?,
because quite frankly it's sounding very silly indeed.

Dave.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Solution #5

posted on Aug 01, 2007
Not Rated (0)

pawa

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Phwoar, at 100MHz? ;)

Yep, I'm well aware of GPS, but I don't want to have to rely on it.
This would be used for sanity checking of GPS data (recently while
walking I apparently travelled east by 80m then back within 2 seconds)
or as a rough backup if the GPS lock is unreliable.

Getting the timing of packet sending and processing to be consistent
is going to be the fun part.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Solution #6

posted on Aug 01, 2007
Not Rated (0)

Charlie

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
It's been done before, so is possible.

Those figures sound about right.

Many micro's have an inbuilt hardware counter that can be externally
clocked.

You are up the right tree, but it's an old tree.
GPS is used now.

Dave.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Solution #7

posted on Aug 01, 2007
Not Rated (0)

Duke

Rank:Apprentice Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
So far so good, but you are a bit late inventing that:

#

Andy Wood
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:

Thank You!

Was the solution helpful?
Show your appreciation by commenting on Can standard components do rough distance measurement?:


I don't want to Accept this solution

Can you Help with these GPS Devices problems?

Garmin Edge 305 GPS Receiver
I have a garmin 305 did the funky thing where it rotated...

Garmin Edge 305 GPS Receiver
I dropped my Garmin 305 on a tile floor and now the...

Garmin Edge 305 GPS Receiver
i need to unlock but dont know the security location i...

Garmin Edge 305 GPS Receiver
I get a wrong elevation on my Garmin Edge 705, it's been...

Garmin Edge 305 GPS Receiver
Hi I can not get the heart rate monitor to pair with the...

Loading problems.

Repair Service

Find GPS Device Repair Service Provider Near You:
Browse the Repair Service Directory
Repair Service Providers, Get Listed FREE

Prescreened Contractors

Get Matched to Prescreened Home Media Professionals

Category
Zip code

When the original poster rates a solution that was given to his own problem, that rating is locked!
X

Are you sure the solution content is Inappropriate?
   
Tech buddies can communicate directly to answer questions. Become a Tech Buddy and have direct access to your favorite expert for FREE!