Sony has been selling the "easy-home-theatre" speaker systems SA-VA3 and SA-VA1 with Dolby Pro-Logic decoding for quite some time.
Their catalogs claim that they use a "Theatre Vision" speaker system to provide a centre channel. Thus no actual centre speaker is needed.
This system has two dedicated tweeters, one on each of the L and R speakers. It is directed to the listener at a 30 degree angle which Sony claims will provide a centre channel as well.
I don't wish to start a flame war on directed sound, but just e-mail me your own opinions please. :)
Has anybody listened to this system before? Does it work well enough for average movie viewing? (I do not need top quality Dolby Pro-Logic sound but if you've got a better recommendation in this price range, do let me know too).
How about your opinions on the sound quality of the SA-VAx systems?
A minor point, the center chanel is 10-20,000 hz, it is sometimes rooled off as in "NORMAL" pro-logic mode at 100hz, but using "WIDE" mode fixes that. Anyway, it is the surrounds that are limited to 100-7000hz. Arther.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on Sony's SA-VAx AV speakers req no centre speaker?:
Solution #2
posted on Aug 01, 2007
Powe33 - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
If the claim of Dolby ProLogic by this manufacturer is true, then they must be decoding a center channel. The description implies that the Center channel is being fed simultaneously to both of the additional tweeters, hopefully resulting in a centered mono experience. This is similar to, and probably permits potentially better quality than the "Phantom" center mode of most ProLogic amps, where the center signal is added simultaneously to the regular front channels.
I regularly use the Phantom mode in my Kenwood system with Cambridge Audio speakers and at reasonable levels, the center channel is excellent. At high levels, the separate speaker helps quite a bit. The reason I use both modes is that my center speaker is an in-wall unit and can be heard in one of the bedrooms (actually it's bathroom) if its loud.
One thing to be aware of is that the center channel frequency range is 100-7000, so hopefully you have dedicated mid-range or full-range speakers rather than tweeters. It might also be interesting to see what the balance control (if any) does to the center experience.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Show your appreciation by commenting on Sony's SA-VAx AV speakers req no centre speaker?:
Solution #3
posted on Aug 01, 2007
Gary10 - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice Rating: 0%, 0 votes
I have listened at length to the Sony SAVA 3 and for its price (800 retail) it is outstanding for movies in a modest room at resonable volumes. Much better than the Bose Lifestyle 12 at 2K (dont flame me, I dont like the Bose line, but it sells well and is what most people really want). Here is what I hear:
Bass is boomy and not very detailed when compared with even modest audiophile speakers (Like PSB Alpha). There is a large amount of dynamic compression and no response below 50Hz or so. Still, it adds excitement to movies and in that context is not objectionable.
Midrange accuracy is what you expect. No low level detail but good intelligibility and fair center fill. Put the towers close to the television (no more than three feet away on either side).
Treble is thin, wiry, and closed in on top. When used as designed (with video tape as a source) this is not a real problem except with music.
For music these things are a poor value.
For movies they play well, add excitment and pan well with the source material. Surround matching is ok. The rear speakers fill in well and you dont hear too obvious a tonal mismatch. Finding brackets to mount the rear speakers is a BITCH. The omnimounts designed for this system are $50 retail (too much). For best results the surrounds need to be at least five feet off the floor and as far behind you as the tv is in front of you. If you cant put them this far away, aim them at the wall and listen to the reflected sound.
One last thing, watch your input levels. A laser player direct in can cause clipping on the input side with all the attendant distortion.
My advice... if you want only a television/movie surround system for cheap, have a set of not more than thirty-five inches in a room of less than 250 square feet, and want ease of use the SAVA 3 is a must audition. Dont expect miracles, but have fun...
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it: