By Luisa_K - usenet poster
I have noticed a very slight light fall off (vignetting) on the corners of the
pictures taken with the AF Nikkor 20 mm. I suspect that this is caused by the
protective Hoya UV filter (not the slim version) on it. I have yet to try the
lens without any filter but I would like to have a filter on at all times.
Is this a problem with the 20 mm? Will a slim filter from Hoya, Nikon or B+W
solve this problem or do I have to live without a filter?
Posted via Deja News, The Discussion Network
# Search, Read, Discuss, or Start Your Own
Best Solution
posted on Aug 01, 2007
pawa - usenet poster
Rank:
Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
If there is a fairly sharp darkening only in the far
corners, this is vignetting, generally caused by a filter
and/or shade that cut into the angle of view of the lens.
If there is a slow roll-off of illumination only at wide
stops, this is normal and it generally is gone by f5.6
in good wide-angle lenses. BTW, much as I like the Nikkor
20mm f2.8 (and consider it one of the very best very-wide
lenses), I do not use it wider than f5.6 (where its
edge/corner performance "hops up" in quality) if at all
possible. (the lens can easily be hand-held at 1/15th, and
even 1/4 second is not difficult...). Lenses have optimum
stops for best performance, and that is one of several
consideration to be included in exposure decisions (which
is partly why I prefer manual exposure determination
to auto modes...).
David Ruether
#
corners, this is vignetting, generally caused by a filter
and/or shade that cut into the angle of view of the lens.
If there is a slow roll-off of illumination only at wide
stops, this is normal and it generally is gone by f5.6
in good wide-angle lenses. BTW, much as I like the Nikkor
20mm f2.8 (and consider it one of the very best very-wide
lenses), I do not use it wider than f5.6 (where its
edge/corner performance "hops up" in quality) if at all
possible. (the lens can easily be hand-held at 1/15th, and
even 1/4 second is not difficult...). Lenses have optimum
stops for best performance, and that is one of several
consideration to be included in exposure decisions (which
is partly why I prefer manual exposure determination
to auto modes...).
David Ruether
#
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Solution #2
posted on Aug 01, 2007
Lizzy - usenet poster
Rank:
Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
My experience with the lens is that @ f2.8 there is noticeable vignetting, @ f4
the problem is still there but far less noticeable, and by f5.6 it is gone. These
were from taking pictures on chrome of a uniformly lit wall (left edge was 0.2
stops under the reading at the right edge, but it was as uniform as I could get).
@ f2.8 I believe the fall-off is something like 1/2 stop, at f4 less than a third.
This test was done without any filter.
the problem is still there but far less noticeable, and by f5.6 it is gone. These
were from taking pictures on chrome of a uniformly lit wall (left edge was 0.2
stops under the reading at the right edge, but it was as uniform as I could get).
@ f2.8 I believe the fall-off is something like 1/2 stop, at f4 less than a third.
This test was done without any filter.
Was this solution helpful? Show your Appreciation by rating it:
Suggest a new solution for this problem
Post a New problem for Nikon 20MM F2.8 AF NIKKOR Lens
Email this problem
Post a New problem for Nikon 20MM F2.8 AF NIKKOR Lens
Email this problem
Can you Help with these Camera Lenses problems?
Repair Service
Find Camera Lense Repairman Near You:
