Question about Car Audio & Video

1 Answer

High x-max vs. high sensitivity

Years ago i had a 15" JBL subwoofer in a ported box in the rear of a camaro. It was running off a rockford fosgate punch amp and was receiving 200 watts rms. This set up worked great and was able to hit 133db with this basic installation. The sub only had a "x-max"of 8.5 mm but had a sensitivity rating of 97db.
My question is this----There are a lot of subs on the market that have a high "x-max" rating of 20-30mm yet have a low sensitivity of 85-90db.If you had 2 choose between the following setup,which would yield the highest bass output and spl in a ported box.>>>A)-15" subwoofer receiving 300-400 watts rms."x-max"-12mm,sensitivity 98db.>>>B)-15" subwoofer receiving 300-400 watts rms. "x-max"-24mm,sensitivity 87db.

Would appreciate any input from anyone out there, especially all the "bassheads"
Thanks..............................

Posted by on

1 Answer

  • Level 3:

    An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

    Superstar:

    An expert that got 20 achievements.

    All-Star:

    An expert that got 10 achievements.

    MVP:

    An expert that got 5 achievements.

  • Master
  • 15,935 Answers

Sensitivity is a representation of efficiency. The higher the efficiency, the better the sound quality.
Xmax is a measure of the "throw of the cone peak to peak. This is a direct representation of the volume of air the subwoofer will displace..
A High X.Max subwoofer will displace more air - and therefore produce more SPL in a vented enclosure.
Sensitivity on these subs aren't crucial, because the customer is looking for LOUD and will purchase a large class D Mono amplifier to power it - characteristically low in sensitivity as well due to the way the power is inverted. Highly efficient, yet low sensitiviy.
I am definately a basshead! My show car has (4) 15" Cerwin Vega Stroker PROs. (one of the most highly EFFICIENT high xmax subs available) (86dB). (36-44mm Xmax (adjustable for SQ or SPL)
High x-max vs. high sensitivity - ea141e4.jpg If you are looking for SPL, High XMax, Low sensitivity, and lots of power is the way to go. Generally, to increas SPL by 3dB, yuo must either increase surface area of driver 2x or double the input power. Slot ports, aeroports, and loaded horn ports can also increase your dB level by up to 3dB as well.
Properly constructed enclosures have an effect as well. Instead of wasting some of your power on vibrating the enclosure, it should be braced properly to reduce the wasted energy.
All of these tips will add tou your satisfaction of the product. You can make a $100 sub sound phenomenal in a proper enclosure, and a $400 sub sound like $hit in a prefab or poorly constructed one.

Your original question - with all things equal except the subwoofer, the subwoofer with the higher Xmax should yield the most SPL - due only to the fact of air displacement.

If you have additional questions or need clarification dont hesitate to ask.

Posted on Jan 15, 2009

  • 1 more comment 
  • BassMutt Feb 12, 2011

    Pure Bs , using speakers with high sensitivity will require less power to achieve higher volume.
    The total SPL is limited by the Number of drivers and the available space, If you wanted to go higher than 133dB you would have to add more Drivers. If you had a pair of drivers rated each at 96dB it would take around 400 watts to reach 130dB.......thats inside a small to med car, the cabin gain adds some SPL. A pair of speakers rated at 86 dB would require well over a 1000watts to reach 130dB.......Cone excursion at 400watts= 9mm, Cone excursion at 1000 watts = 26mm , so you can see both systems will both reach their xmax and power handling and still get the same SPL. The big benefit of using high Xmax drivers is clean, tight accurate bass at " normal " listening levels......If you want high SPL you need high SPL drivers...and a high spl driver will have less xmax, so more likely to hit distortion, if you still want high SPL and low distortion you need to use more drivers....such as 4 instead of 2....so
    2 speakers, each at 97dB with 400 watts = 127 dB with cabin gain 130 to 136dB
    4 speakers, each at 97dB with 400 watts = 131 dB with cabin gain 134 to 140dB

  • adam eldridge Jan 09, 2012

    yur right and wrong 2 10'' subs at 400w rms = 146.7 db learn how to install before u act like u know sumthin i have beatin 2000w multi driver systems with a mere 600w on a single sub rightn now im running a 50 dollar kicker with a 300 w amp and my dbs are touching 129 and thats country music but yes higher eff. levels equal more db with less power

  • amoctez2
    amoctez2 Apr 16, 2013

    You add 6dB when you double power(dB is measured as ratio of powers not voltages!). But at high powers, efficiency is lowered (the nonlinearity depends on the sub you are testing). Therefore, all those theoretical calculations just give approximations. There's nothing like measuring at the resonant frequency.

×

1 Suggested Answer

6ya6ya
  • 2 Answers

SOURCE: I have freestanding Series 8 dishwasher. Lately during the filling cycle water hammer is occurring. How can this be resolved

Hi,
a 6ya expert can help you resolve that issue over the phone in a minute or two.
best thing about this new service is that you are never placed on hold and get to talk to real repairmen in the US.
the service is completely free and covers almost anything you can think of (from cars to computers, handyman, and even drones).
click here to download the app (for users in the US for now) and get all the help you need.
goodluck!

Posted on Jan 02, 2017

Add Your Answer

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

1 Answer

At high levels sounds more like a thump than boom


Make sure the GAIN on the amp is not all the way up it is not a loud button. your amp should be tuned to your subs with the GAIN or on some LEVEL. if they are not matched you will clip the amp and subs and blow them.Is it in the proper sized box? is the amp able to run the sub at the ohm it needs to be run at and do you have the the ohm load correct on the sub. there is a lot to it. if your not familiar with it go to youtube and watch some videos there is some good vids there and will help you learn to wire a sub correctly i have enclosed a link easy to use.
Rockford Fosgate Woofer WiringWizard

Mar 07, 2016 | Rockford Fosgate Car Audio & Video

1 Answer

Box specs for 1 fosgate hx2 12 for a jeep wrangler


go to the rockford fosgate site they will have info you need.

Oct 07, 2012 | Rockford Fosgate Punch HX2 RFD1212 Car...

1 Answer

Subwoofers have a humming noise


You can purchase a filter at any authorized auto audio store and also try a high resistor spark plug in the vehicle such as bosch platinum plugs.

Apr 05, 2011 | Rockford Fosgate Car Audio & Video

1 Answer

Yes im trying to figure out what the airspace for a rockford fosgate p1 12 in sub. i want to build a ported box for it to put in a entertainment room


Hello... I can help you with this. The correct airspace for a p1 Fosgate 12 is 1.79 cubic ft. I don't think the performanace of a car audio sub will be the best choice for a home audio application, though I hear of it being done on many occasions. Just that the design of the sub is different for different applications, car, home, p.a., etc. Hope this helped! Good luck with your venture!

20 year car audio installer

Mar 14, 2011 | Rockford Fosgate Car Audio & Video

1 Answer

How do u wire a mofo 15 down to 1 ohm


see this link put in your info i dont think you can run it at 1 ohm you would need two subs at 4 ohms.
Rockford Fosgate Woofer WiringWizard

Sep 12, 2010 | Power Acoustik MOFO-15 Car Subwoofer

1 Answer

When my bass hits, my car lights flicker.


Is the problem much more noticeable when the car is at idle? Double check that Alternator output. 70 amps is not high output, and if the problem is especially noticeable at idle, it's probably due to the alternator putting out lower voltage( a common thing with alternators). Also, with that much draw from your sub amp, the wire from battery to alternator should be beefed up, as well as the ground wire from battery. You can make up your own cables by purchasing the wire to length and wire lugs at a local Welding shop, 4 gauge from alternator to battery is good. High output aftermarket Alternators shoot into the 200 amp range.

Aug 20, 2009 | Rockford Fosgate P112-200 Car Subwoofer

1 Answer

Rockford sub squeaks


Hello markwasicki,

You did not specify what type of enclosure the subs are in or if they share the same airspace. But the sound you describe sounds suspiciously like the enclosure is at fault and not the sub itself.

Remove and reverse the subs in the box and test for the noise again. If the noise is still produced on the same side of the box, it's the enclosure. If the noise follows the sub, then you have a problem with that sub.

If the box is making the noise, and it's a ported box, you probably have "port noise". If it's a sealed enclosure, you could have either an air leak or flexing noise. In either case, repair the enclosure or put the subs in a new one. If the sub itself is making the noise, there probably isn't much you can do. Most likely some part of the voice coil assembly is touching where it should not.

Hope this helps.

Apr 18, 2009 | Rockford Fosgate (P212D4) Car Subwoofer

1 Answer

15 in subs wont trun on


Hello. You can call Sound Repair 321-690-0808 for estimate.

Jan 26, 2009 | Rockford Fosgate (P210D4) Car Subwoofer

Not finding what you are looking for?
Car Audio & Video Logo

Related Topics:

1,715 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Car Audio & Video Experts

xxxxxx xxx

Level 3 Expert

4724 Answers

Donald DCruz
Donald DCruz

Level 3 Expert

17129 Answers

yadayada
yadayada

Level 3 Expert

63242 Answers

Are you a Car Audio and Video Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...