Question about Conair Weight Watchers WW-87 Body Fat Glass Scale
The scale is on a flat level tile floor. I step on it without clothes on, and barefoot. All of the user info is entered correctly. I am a male, 23 years old, 5'9 and 150 lbs. I barely have a inch of fat on me. It is telling me that I have 18.9% bf. I had my bf% measured at GNC, and their scale read 8.4%. Is this just a faulty scale?
Unfortunately, it's the scale, but it's not broken. It simply is telling you inaccurate information.
Some scales utilize Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) technology. BIA uses very low levels of electrical impulses running from one metal contact point/lead to another. Your body acts as the connector between the two contact points, thus completing the circuit. Not all scales use this means for calculating body fat percentage due to poor reliability and high fabrication costs.This method of measurement requires very large contact points, as well as clean and moist skin exposure. If you have dry/calluced feet, which is normal for most Americans, the sensors can not accurately measure due to skin resistance. Dry skin acts as a resistor to electrical impulse. Electricity passes through muscle and fat at different rates. However, its measurements may be thrown off by how hydrated you are and how much you've eaten; it may be too inaccurate for anything other than comparative use. Users are encouraged to establish a baseline measurement and repeat measurements under consistent conditions over time to detect changes.
Many less expensive models simply use a body-fat calculator to average your imputed height in inches, waist measurement in inches and the current weight measurement recorded in lbs. The scale compares your measurement with the ideal norms inputed during the manufactoring process, thus giving you a comparison vs.imputed norms. People who are very, very fit can get numbers 3 to 5 percent higher than their true percent body fat. Because they don't have a lot of fat inside their muscles(visceral fat), the simple tape measure calculation test cannot adjust as it should indicate.
Conversely, if a person is skinny but not fit, this body fat test may yield a number 3 to 5 percent lower than his or her true percent body fat. Though they look thin, unfit skinny people really have more than the usual amount of fat inside their muscles, which you can't see from the outside.
In either case, the scale is not necessary a measurement tool, due to high variables of test inaccuracy and interuser reliabilty; but, it is a good tool for comparing whether or not you are gaining/losing body fat.
If you would like a more accurate tool for simply measuring your body fat, you can pick up some pinch-calipers online for about the price of a scale. They come with an instructional pamphlet, very easy to use.
Posted on Jan 13, 2009
Tips for a great answer:
May 14, 2016 | Scales & Body Fat Analyzers
Jan 15, 2012 | Scales & Body Fat Analyzers
Jul 15, 2011 | Taylor 5599 440 Pound Tempered Glass Body...
May 21, 2011 | Health-O-Meter Scales & Body Fat Analyzers
Feb 28, 2010 | Conair WW60 Weightwatchers Scale
Oct 12, 2009 | Taylor Body Fat Analyzer & Scale, Model...
Jul 02, 2009 | Taylor 5757 Digital Glass Body Fat Scale
Dec 20, 2008 | Conair Weight Watchers WW-87 Body Fat...
558 people viewed this question
Usually answered in minutes!