Home | All Products | 250GB MyBook External USB 2.0 250 GB Hard Drive | Tips

If your HD Clicks and doesn't start SMACK IT!


kinggeorg
By Apprentice kinggeorg
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 95%, 11 votes
posted on Feb 04, 2009
Helpful

My hard drive was dead and wasn't recognized by the computer, it didn't even start, just a few clicking noises, which according to some of the experiences is the same as a DEAD Hardisk. Anyways, as I read that sometimes this happens as a result of a hit, well, I wacked my HD as a last hope for it to recover its "memory" (as in the movies) and believe me or not, it worked! I don't know if this might help yours, but it saved mine! 
The way I did it was like this: I started the pc and when the HD started to run and I heard a couple of clicks, I hit it against the table while in vertical position (assuming that the arm of the HD might slightly move better that way) one time, and then when the spinning and the first click was heard agin I hit again. After that I heard the typical searching sound of a HD, and you can imagine I started to pray that what I heard wasn't my anxiety sound (if it has any). Now I am a firm believer in the old trick of whacking the old TV to get the vital signal back! 
Good luck to you too!

Was this helpful?
Yes
No
7 people thought this was helpful

Comment #1

posted on Jun 03, 2009

scorpioooooo
By Master scorpioooooo
Rank: Master
Rating: 75%, 3 votes

WARNING!

Smacking your HDD may get it working again but you need to be aware that doing so is very likely to cause more damage that will not manifest until it's been used for a while. It may fail in an hour, a day a week or a month, but it will eventually fail. This method is a LAST RESORT and is unreliable In the long run. If a drive has become unreliable it should be replaced.

The shock, or G-force, from whacking the HDD may temporarily resolve only SOME problems such as a stuck head or a bad Voice Coil Actuator (VCA). The clicking sound comes from the VCA. Most drives will click two to four times, then the platters will spin down. If the VCA is good but the pre-amp on the controller located on the bottom of the HDD is cooked you can smack it all you want but it will not resolve the problem. In fact, it will only make recovering data far more difficult and lead to a deeper sense of misery and despair. A blown pre-amp can make the drive tick the same way a bad VCA or stuck head may. DO NOT DEPEND ON THE TICK SOUND AS A RELIABLE DIAGNOSTIC METHOD.

Before abusing your HDD, carefully inspect the circuit board located on the bottom of the drive for any scorching. If you are very handy and know what a torx head is, you may also try to remove the PCB to inspect the other side where most if not all of the components are located. If you are a klutz or have no experience with electronics, do not attempt removal of the PCB, doing so will only make matters worse. Try sniffing the PCB, you may detect a slightly charred or acrid scent. If this is the case, you will have to send your drive to a professional data recovery house. Recovery is expensive, usually $750 or more. That alone is enough to justify investing $100 to $200 for a back up drive and the two whole minutes it takes to run a backup program. 100% of data loss is preventable if you back up your shiiiiii.......if you back up your data. To learn more about the clicking sound, Google "click of death".

Another method for temporarily getting a ticking/grinding/screaming HDD to work again is to put it in an air tight plastic bag, squeeze out as much air as possible and stick it in the freezer for an hour or two. Before you re-connect the drive to your computer, BE VERY VERY SURE that there is no condensation (water droplets) anywhere on the drive. If you live in a humid climate, this is very likely to happen. If you do not allow time for the HDD to dry out before re-attaching it, otherwise, YOU MAY FRY YOUR ENTIRE COMPUTER. Dry is good.

If you do manage to get the drive working, use the limited time it may work again wisely. Begin the recovery or backup process immediatly.

Scorpio

Comment #2

posted on May 29, 2009

phoenix911
By Apprentice phoenix911
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes

same problem here.........clicks n all......
After smacking the external hard disk gets detected...the drivers are installed...even the 'safely remove hardware' icon is there in the task bar...but the icon doesn't appear in the My Computer folder.......
Help me out..........please..........SOS

Comment #3

posted on May 20, 2009

zionk1010
By Apprentice zionk1010
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes

Thanks! My 4 year old MP3 player - Creative Zen with a 8 gig Seagate ST 1.2 Hard Drive- finally hit the pavement today. When I tried to use it, it made buzzing noise and stared back at with me with a never-ending power-up screen. I thumped it a few times lightly with no luck, then I disassembled it to get at the HD. Then I firmly slammed each side of the HD against my desk, trying it after each smack. the third time did it! I figured it was bad luck since I just bought 2 new batteries a few months ago.. take that, Murphy!

Comment #4

posted on Apr 28, 2009

cagileal
By Apprentice cagileal
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 75%, 2 votes

OMG! it worked!
I have a 500 gb seagate and I dropped it very hard on the floor. When I plugged it on there was this buzzing sound.I was very desperate.... But couple of minutes ago after I read this I tried pounding it to the table Vertically! it started working! Try this solution before you go and buy a new external drive, you wont lose anything.

Thanks kinggeorg

Comment #5

posted on Mar 24, 2009

ve2adq
By Apprentice ve2adq
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes

the same for mine external HD

Comment #6

posted on Feb 12, 2009

lmwood
By Apprentice lmwood
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes

Just curious, was it an external drive?? Thanks

Comment by lmwood, posted on Feb 12, 2009

NM, I see that it is external, I;ll have to try that on mine now, it stopped working on Saturday, now it just clicks.

Can you Help with these Hard Drives problems?

Western Digital 250GB MyBook External USB...
I have a Mybook Studio connected to my iMac and linked to...

Western Digital 250GB MyBook External USB...
By sowhatbks on Oct 06, 2009" " As of this...

Western Digital 250GB MyBook External USB...
i can see the disk in my computer i have a lot of files on...

Western Digital 250GB MyBook External USB...
As of this morning my Western Digital Ebook (mdl #...

Western Digital 250GB MyBook External USB...
It goes 2 sleep during boot up it gets to the bar thingy...

Sponsored Links

Ask our Experts

 

Solve Your Problem Now!
Chat Live with an Expert
Chat Now

Top Computer & Laptop Repair

(877) 934-6198
Send your laptop to us and we will diagnose the...
A+ Rated Oceanside Computer Sales & Service, LLC

(952) 890-7770
Zkarlo.com provides discount and used laptop parts...
Zkarlo.com