Question about Harley Davidson FXSTS Springer Softail Motorcycles

1 Answer

I have a 98 springer softail that makes a "clunk" when starting warm. it seems to be fine when starting cold. it sounds bad, but I've known people that have had the same problem, and they just sort of live with it. Bottom end is stock, new cams, carb, pipes, wide tire kit. could it be the jack shaft was installed incorrectly?

Posted by on

  • ryszki5 Dec 29, 2013

    Having same problem with my 98 Heritage. Starts up pretty easy when it is cold. When it is warm, it turns over fine but over 50% of the time it will clunk after 2-3 seconds if the engine does not start. Three years ago I had my starter rebuilt. That solved the problem then. Guess it is time to rebuild it again. Did you come up with a solution as to what was the clunk?



1 Answer

  • Level 3:

    An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points


    An expert that got 10 achievements.


    An expert that got 5 achievements.

    Brigadier General:

    An expert that has over 10,000 points.

  • Master
  • 4,565 Answers

It's kind of difficult to install a jackshaft incorrectly. It' will only go in one way and the little bolt ain't that much.

Now, when you hear the clunk, does there seem to be any delay between the time you punch the start button and when you hear the noise. If so, it could be the contacts in your starter's solenoid. Remove the five sided plate from the end of the starter solenoid. The plate is held on by three small screws. Remove the plate, pull the plunger and spring out. Look into the solenoid and you'll see two large copper contacts. Are they burned to where they are not smooth anymore but have a arcing "step" in one of the contacts that matches the radius on the plunger. If so, you may need to replace these contacts. They aren't that expensive.

What I think might be happening is the plunger is pulling the into the solenoid and that kicks the jackshaft out against the outer primary cover. Usually, the starter motor is running by this time but because your contacts may be burned, there's a slight delay in the motor starting up. This enables you to hear the "clunk" where otherwise all you would hear is the engine turning over.

Good Luck

Posted on Nov 07, 2010


1 Suggested Answer

  • 2 Answers

SOURCE: I have freestanding Series 8 dishwasher. Lately during the filling cycle water hammer is occurring. How can this be resolved

A 6ya expert can help you resolve that issue over the phone in a minute or two.
Best thing about this new service is that you are never placed on hold and get to talk to real repairmen in the US.
The service is completely free and covers almost anything you can think of (from cars to computers, handyman, and even drones).
click here to download the app (for users in the US for now) and get all the help you need.
Good luck!

Posted on Jan 02, 2017


Add Your Answer

Uploading: 0%


Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add



Related Questions:

1 Answer

Harley wiring diagam 1996 softail

What wiring diagram. There are more than one. You would likley be best to obtain an service manual.

May 03, 2014 | 2000 Harley Davidson FXSTS Springer...

1 Answer

1972 olds 98 455ci starts and runs fine when its cold but once i've driven it for awhile it starts sputtering like its running out of gas

sounds like a vapor lock. older cars needed a set of points . they kept firing times in sync with fuel delivery , valves opening/closing try that.

Jul 29, 2012 | 1972 Oldsmobile 98

1 Answer

I have a 2000 Heritage Softail Springer. Recently the starter makes an extremely loud grinding sound intermittently when I try to start it. It doesn't do it every time but sounds really bad when it...

This could be several old is your battery? if it isn't holding a full charge it sometimes won't have the cranking amps to fully engage the starter. It could be the solenoid or the starter itself but I would start with the battery.

Jun 06, 2011 | 2000 Harley Davidson FLHR-FLHRI Road king

1 Answer

I just purchased a 2003 heritage springer classic with 4100 miles. The engine sounds seem high, higher than my 1994 low rider. Is this common ? Ed

Hard to tell what engine sounds mean, from your description. But they should sound similar.
Issues on newer machine are valve tapping. But hey, you could be talking about exhaust system....

Sep 06, 2010 | 2003 Harley Davidson FXSTS Springer...

1 Answer

Hello, I have an 07 Springer Softail. My problem is that the front end is stiff, really movement at all. I took the shock off and it seems fine. It's like the front end is a rigid.

If your bike responds normally while riding upon the road and if during front braking the springs directly behind the headlight "extend" and "relax" in a "normal" fashion then you aren't experiencing any difficulties/problems. Springer front ends should only be adjusted or serviced by very qualified personnel as the spring pressures exerted by a springer assembly can seriously injure untrained persons.

Aug 07, 2010 | 2000 Harley Davidson FXSTS Springer...

1 Answer

I have 2003 Springer FXSTSI with 10600 miles on it and it just recently started making a knocking noise that sounds like its coming from the base of the rear cylinder. The oil level is fine and it doesnt...

Sounds like a main bearing. The bad news is the only ways I know of to chack it are, 1)tear the motor down and check for play, or 2)run it till it goes and risk ruining the motor. Sorry, I know it sucks. I just rebuilt a Kawasucki with the same problem. At least the Harley is an easier rebuild.

Jun 24, 2009 | 2003 Harley Davidson FXSTS Springer...

1 Answer

Starter issues

try tapping on the starter motor/solenoid, it sounds like the solenoind is engaging(the clunk you hear) but the starter is not turning if the wire is getting hot it could be the starter is frozen up.

Jun 19, 2009 | 2004 Harley Davidson FXSTS - FXSTSI...

1 Answer

98 Jimmy 4WD clunk

It seems like no one else hear at FixYa is responding yet to both your requests about clunking in 4wd.
I see two the first a 2000 blazer from Gloeckz
there is a rapid clunking in 4wd!
In the second it clunks hard going in then won't drive!
This is rayenc11s' 98 Jimmy 4WD clunk I'm no trans specialist and not familiar with repairing or troubleshooting serious 4wd problems but it sounds like this may be a problem in the transfer case.

Since no one seems to be helping you but me I'd suggest you go to a transmission shop and ask them if this is a common problem that may lead to a bad transfer case if not corrected!

Make sure you have the proper fluid in your transmission case, transfer case and differential case first or have a quick oil change place check it for you!

Hope this is helpful.

Good Luck!
c04bf14.jpg jackiaria

Jan 05, 2009 | 2001 Chevrolet Blazer

1 Answer

Cake Display Freezer Compressor keeps freezer cold

Maybe the guy meant the compressor is going bad.

Jul 24, 2017 | Traulsen Reach in Freezer - G12010

Not finding what you are looking for?
Motorcycles Logo

Related Topics:

105 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Harley Davidson Experts

Arnie Burke
Arnie Burke

Level 3 Expert

4821 Answers


Level 3 Expert

4348 Answers


Level 3 Expert

79024 Answers

Are you a Harley Davidson Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides