Question about 1999 Volkswagen Beetle

1 Answer

The 1999 VW Bug I own kept overheating. It won't hold compression to keep running. Mechanic says needs new engine. Worth it to fix?

Posted by on


1 Answer

  • Level 3:

    An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points


    An expert that got 10 achievements.


    An expert that got 5 achievements.


    An expert whose answer got voted for 500 times.

  • Master
  • 1,915 Answers

I kind of depends on how you feel about it-did he tell you what the compression readings were? Are they all low, or just one cylinder? Is the reason top end (valves) or rings (bottom end)-he should know these numbers and why if he is recommending engine replacement. you don't say how many miles, and you know the car's maintenance history, but if regular oil changes have not been done, if it has been badly overheated, it may be the only thing you can do. A second opinion never hurts especially if he cannot say what compression numbers are, or if the valves or rings are the cause of low compression.

And it depends on the cost-a used engine can be installed, but you have to decide if it is worth the cost of the engine, installation and down time. Consider the value of your car-you can go onto used car websites and get a valuation number for your car by plugging in condition, miles, etc to determine it's worth. Subtract from that number the cost of installing a new engine and you have an idea of what your car is worth right now-probably not alot as I'd guess the cost of a used engine and installation would run from a low of $1200 to as much as $2000 and your car is worth about $3-3500. You could buy an inexpensive car to get you by while you look for a good used engine, and locate a shop to do the install, then sell the beater car when you are back on the road with your Beetle.

Posted on Mar 22, 2011


1 Suggested Answer

  • 2 Answers

SOURCE: I have freestanding Series 8 dishwasher. Lately during the filling cycle water hammer is occurring. How can this be resolved

Hi there,
Save hours of searching online or wasting money on unnecessary repairs by talking to a 6YA Expert who can help you resolve this issue over the phone in a minute or two.

Best thing about this new service is that you are never placed on hold and get to talk to real repairmen in the US.

Here's a link to this great service

Good luck!

Posted on Jan 02, 2017


Add Your Answer

Uploading: 0%


Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add



Related Questions:

1 Answer

I have a 2000 vw bug the timing belt broke at road

The 2.0 gas engine is an interference engine. So chances are the valves are damaged.
You won't know for sure until you install the new belt and check compression.

Aug 31, 2014 | Cars & Trucks

1 Answer

VW 2002 NEW BEETLE replaced engine and problems are on going. Epc light and ABS come on aling with check engine light. I was told that problem is that the "modules" we not synced? Now VW Dealership wants...

any time engine replaced need diagnostic equipment to relearn PCM and TCM to engine before vechicle will run correctly.most all newer vechicle same procedure has to be done.

Oct 06, 2013 | Cars & Trucks

1 Answer

2001 Saab 9-3 seized engine

Only if overheated bad enough, it could seize up the engine. But if it was seized, there is no way to do a compression test. ?? Take the bas***** to court. If truly no compression, the engine is shot, they didn't overlook anything, but they should be liable for a new engine- a warranty is a warranty or it is worthless. Sue them!

Jul 17, 2013 | Saab Cars & Trucks

1 Answer


Hello Joe,
If the engine has over heated it may have blown the head gasket, you say the engine noise changed and you have power loss, get a mechanic to check it and try not to drive it

Oct 23, 2012 | 1999 Volkswagen Golf

1 Answer

Jeep was overheating, Now leaking transmision fluid and won't start

I don't see how leaking transmission fluid would be connected to the engine overheating, unless the radiator blew up.
You'll need to figure out why it won't start to proceed.
Check for spark and fuel pressure, and of course compression.
Is the check engine light on ?

Jul 09, 2012 | 1988 Jeep Cherokee

1 Answer

I have a 1994 Dodge intrepid 3.3 engine Just have New Radiator, Water Pump and Therma stat placed in car. However the Car kept leaking Fluid out of The coolant tank. My mechanic fixed that by Pressurising...

1) Your car should have a thermostat regardless of what your mechanic says. Fuel injected vehicles run better and more efficient at proper temperatures. So re-install thermostat properly before step 2.
2) Did the mechanic make sure the heater was on high temperature and blower on when he re-filled the cooling system?
Maybe not. So start engine when cool and rad cap off. Fill rad about an inch from the top and let the engine run up to normal operating temperature and keep an eye on coolant level in rad and keep it topped up as it's running. Rev the engine slightly for 5 seconds or so every once in a while to help with flow and pressure to make sure coolant is getting to and through heater core. Keep observing flow in rad to make sure it's good, when thermostat opens. You won't see much movement until thermostat opens at normal operating temperature, then you should see flow in rad and shortly after, rad fan should come on.Leave rad cap off and heater on until the rad fan comes on and off 3 or 4 times to make sure all air is out of the system. Then, make sure rad is topped up, put rad cap back on and fill return bottle to proper level. If that doesn't cure your overheating, then something was done wrong, or you have a possible head gasket problem but proper diagnosis should be done by a competent mechanic. What was the car doing initially to warrant these repairs, overheating?

Apr 08, 2012 | 1994 Dodge Intrepid

2 Answers

Vw beetle running hot and we cannot find a leak

have them check the compression sounds like you might have a head gasket problem

Mar 15, 2017 | 2005 Volkswagen New Beetle Convertible

1 Answer

Daughters 1999 turbo bettle started overheating today. Red light appeared on dash. water gushed out when resivor cap removed. engine [while running] would not take new water, water kept gushing back. then...


Aug 21, 2010 | Volkswagen Beetle Cars & Trucks

4 Answers

Why my 1999 oldsmobile alero runnig hot after I've gotten it fix

there may be air trapped in the coolant system. the fans may not be connected since you had the radiator replaced. bring it back to the mechanic who did the work and tell him your not satisfied.he should be responsible for the discrepany.

Apr 23, 2010 | 1999 Oldsmobile Alero

2 Answers

1999 nissan altima, overheated and no leaks after fluid replinished, but car will start and then shut off after a few minutes.

check to see if your engine oil and antifreeze are mixing.if overheated you burned ur head gasket car will not turn on because it loosing engine compression. to check this you need to do compression test..ur engine will seize if you keep starting it.and letting it keep shutting off.keep damage to a minimum internally

Apr 04, 2010 | 1999 Nissan Altima

Not finding what you are looking for?
1999 Volkswagen Beetle Logo

128 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Volkswagen Experts

Colin Stickland
Colin Stickland

Level 3 Expert

22326 Answers


Level 3 Expert

80263 Answers

Jeffrey Turcotte
Jeffrey Turcotte

Level 3 Expert

8841 Answers

Are you a Volkswagen Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides