1991 Honda Civic Logo
Anonymous Posted on Oct 31, 2010

Ok, here's a doosie for ya, I have a 91 civic, 5 speed manual with 185k miles on it. A few weeks ago it started making an awful noise coming from the area of the bell housing. It sounds like metal rubbing (not grinding) on metal. The noise is there on and off when idleing, regardless if clutch is in or out, but is really loud when the car is moving in reverse, 1st and 2nd gear. The noise backs off a bit when in 3rd and is completely gone when in 4th and 5th gear. I took it to a mechanic's shop, he listened and then told me to replace the starter, because he thinks the flywheel is catching and that is what is causing the noise. I replaced the starter, the noise was completely gone for a week or so, but from one day to the next came back, this time much worse. The clutch and cable are barely a year old and the flywheel was machined when the clutch was replaced. I have no problems shifting gears, nor is there any problem in the way the car drives, handles, accelerates, etc... The only consistancy is that the noise gets quieter as the engine gets hotter, although it never goes away. So, if it is the starter, could it be that it requires a shim or something. I've looked for such a thing, but am not able to locate any info regarding the subject nor have I found a suitable shim from any manufacturer. The new starter I installed is the same part I removed, a NAPA brand remanufactured nippondenso starter, part number 2446107. Please help me!!! Thanks for your time.

  • Anonymous Nov 01, 2010

    Hi Johngee,
    I've pin pointed the noise, it's loudest right where there starter connects to the engine.
    To answer your questions 1) I was told the seals on the axle were bad and leaking fluid.
    2) Due to the fluid leak, it made the changes diffficult, the cluth was not slipping, there was just no more room for adjustment anymore.
    3) Right now, I have to depress the clutch about half way before it engages.
    I've also noticed that whae the car is idleing and making the noise, if I depress the clutch and take it out of gear, it slowly gets quieter until it's completely gone.
    Jailer

×

1 Answer

Boundless Company Limited

Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

  • Honda Master 2,122 Answers
  • Posted on Oct 31, 2010
Boundless Company Limited
Honda Master
Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Answers
2122
Questions
9
Helped
685626
Points
4449

I think your gear box will have to come out, because I believe what you're hearing, is a damaged bearing....I can't recall if your car uses a pilot bearing, but I believe it does and that one would be a suspect.
Another of the bearing's that could cause the problem, is the clutch release bearing. If that has been over adjusted and is in constant contact with the pressure plate (clutch cover), it will give the symptoms you talk about.
As the box has been removed during the past, have you checked the gear box oil level?
If it's dry or the oil level very low, the gearbox input shaft bearing could be damaged.
I do not believe the noise has anything to do with the starter motor!
As the noise is obvious during idling, start the engine and while it's idling....With a very long screw driver, pin point the noise in this way.....Take off anything dangling from around your neck and don't wear loose clothing....Give your neighbors a treat, and if necessary.... remove anything that can get caught anywhere....
Take the long screw driver and place the business end in firm contact with the engine block behind the front of the bell housing, close to the starter motor and press your ear to the handle....You'll hear the noise....Now change the place to listen on top of the bell housing.....and then to the gear box side of the bell housing....If the noise is loudest in the front, then suspect the pilot bearing....Middle or top,...suspect the thrust bearing....With this one have someone press and release the clutch pedal while you listen for any changes in frequency ....Gear box side input bearing....
Once we know more about the problem, if you would like to tackle it yourself let me know and we'll go on from there....
Now put your shirt back on and wave to all your new friends....Best regards Johngee10

  • 2 more comments 
  • Anonymous Oct 31, 2010

    Thanks for the quick reply, Johngee10!
    As soon as I get home from work, I'll try and pin point the noise.
    Unfortunately i'm not much of a mechanic, I can do minor parts changing and maintanance. After that i'm forced to trust a repair shop! But I always feel like i'm getting ripped off, so i will just extend my knowledge and takle the problem myself, with your help of course!!
    The gear box oil is fine, I checked that right off. A while back I was having some problems shifting, so the repair shop told me that my gear box seals were bad and my clutch needs changing. I had them replace the clutch, clutch cable and the seals. This took place about a year ago.
    So, if it were to be the release bearing, wouldn't the noise be dependant upon clutch engagement?
    Why do you think the noise goes away in higher gears?
    Should I release some tension in the clutch cable and give that a try?

  • Do what I've suggested first and try to locate and pin point the sound.
    The release bearing can sometimes make a noise even when not depressed....We'll take it from there....And this time make sure you're wearing a short sleeved shirt....

    Best regards Johngee

  • Hi Jailer,
    Just read through your reply again and have some questions.
    What seals were gone?
    Was the clutch slipping last year before the job, or were the changes just difficult?
    How high does the clutch pedal have to be before the clutch engages?

    Regards Johnhgee

  • Anonymous Nov 01, 2010

    Hi Johngee,
    to answer your questions:
    The seals on the axels were gone causing it to leak oil, also causing the gear changes to be very difficult, sometimes not possible at all. The mechanic told me he checked everything when he had it apart and couldn't find anything damaged. The clutch was not slipping but there was no room for any adjustment left on the clutch cable and I had to almost press the clutch through the floor board! So I was told it's time to replace the clutch. As of right now, I have to depress the clutch about 1/2 to 3/4 down before it engages, depending on how warmed up the engine is.
    I did what you said and I'm sure the sound is loudest right where the starter is bolted.

×

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

1helpful
1answer

What is the growling noise coming from my 94 civic motor

Water pump or pulley most likely.

Always replace water pump and pulleys when you do the timing belt.

Also you may have overtightened the belt.

NOTE, Kevlar belts will make a "whirring" noise for a few thousand miles after replacement, but not a growling.
0helpful
1answer

Seat Leon 1.9 TDI, not starting

Get rid of it, and buy an other bullock cart.
0helpful
1answer

My 2005 Honda Civic has what I think is a tappet noise for about 5 minutes when first driving off with a cold engine. There is no tappet noise when starting and letting the car idle before driving away. ...

indicates a problem hydraulic cam followers leaking down when let sit for a time
they can be removed and checked with a leak down test but for the years and the mileage , it may be best to just replace them with new units
0helpful
1answer

2004 Honda Civic fan noise in dashboard area

My first guess is a front wheel bearing is going bad.
0helpful
1answer

91 four door civic distributor problem doubt.

It is very possible that the lock down bolt, which allows adjustment of timing, has come loose. Re-set timing and tighten down bolt.
Also the rotor button screw may have fallen out allowing the button to turn. Pull the distributor cap to check.


FixYaYaWIZ................saailer


I’m happy to help further over the phone at https://www.6ya.com/expert/david_6df67de3b14de867

1helpful
1answer

My daughter's 1990 Honda Civic occasionally will not start. It cranks fine, but it will not turn over. Usually, if she waits anywhere from 5-15 minutes, trying to start it every few minutes, it will crank...

if the car just wine's when starting like it would normally and nothng is happening...Check for fuel, either find the fuel pressure relief valve near the rear of the engine, and depress the valve stem (fuel should hit the roof of hood) if not then its a fuel problem, try this a couple times, but turning the key over, and listen for noise from the gas t ank to see if the pump is actuating.. if you hear the noise while just turn the keyy to acc, not start plz comment back that you hear it , but its still doesnt start....
hope this fix's-ya!
1helpful
1answer

Car looses power when i come to a stop & have to accelarte quickl

Did they Replace the Fuel Filter???? It sounds like the Fuel Filter has a Minor Clog and needs to be Replaced. Please Rate My Response! Thanks!
0helpful
2answers

The engine will not turn over at all

Possibly could be the starter. About the only this I can tell you to try would be to tap on the starter wile someone else is trying to start it. If if cranks, you will need a starter. This is the easyist way to check it without a machine.

I’m happy to assist further over the phone at https://www.6ya.com/expert/jonathan_3a3c556b4b17d1d2

Not finding what you are looking for?

343 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Honda Experts

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

Ronny Bennett Sr.
Ronny Bennett Sr.

Level 3 Expert

6988 Answers

Thomas Perkins
Thomas Perkins

Level 3 Expert

15088 Answers

Are you a Honda Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...