Solution #2
posted on May 14, 2008
Bomber - usenet poster
Rank: Apprentice
Rating: 0%, 0 votes
Brent Irvine & Dianne Lancia <
Brent,
I drove one (a 2000) late last summer for over a week while my 1987
98 Touring Sedan was disabled waiting parts. I've also driven numerous
GM "W" body cars (your present Cutlass is a "W" body), so I think I
can give you a good comparison on how the 2 cars drive.
I rather like the Intrigue - would not trade my 98 for one, but not
a bad car. Nice tight handling, decent ride even on the crappy streets
of San Francisco (it even handles crossing the Muni tracks without
losing it's composure). The car is much more "civilized" than the "W"
body (less body roll, better control in braking and better steering
control), though the ride can be a bit "busy" at time.
Engine and transmission are smooth - good acceleration (with 215 HP
it should be :)) Gas mileage was not bad, even though I'll admit I did
"lead foot" it a bit once I got past 500 miles (I picked up the car
with 13 miles on it). The "Shortstar" V-6 is a takeoff on the Aurora
and Cadillac V-8s, and is a well-running engine. However, it's long
term reliability is still an open book, and this engine does NOT lend
itself well to DIY repair (because of all the special tools required).
Based on the history of the Cadillac 4.6L and the Aurora 4.0L V-8s,
the engine will run well but will be expensive to fix if something
goes wrong. You could look at the Pontiac GP as an alternative: it has
the well-proven Gen II 3.8L Buick V-6 instead of the new V-6.
As far as "creature comforts", the HVAC system has a problem in
holding a constant temp - seems to wander a bit (and in heat mode has
a tendency to overshoot a bit). The car I had had the
AM/FM/Cassette/CD radio (non-BOSE) - good sound, good balance, good
sensivitity on FM but a bit lame on AM (I think that is more a
function of the rear window antenna and not the radio itself). Rear
seat kinda tight with the front one set back; front seat lumbar
support kinda lame, otherwise seats are good (just for the record, I'm
6'3" and 250 lbs.).
If you are tall, be careful getting into and out of the car: that
"A" pillar has a bit of a rake and you'll hit your head a few times
until you get used to the difference with that 94 Cutlass (as I did
with my 98).
Took a look under the hood while I had the car: serviceability SUCKS
vs my 87 Olds 98 (the 98 has a 3.8L V-6 in an engine compartment big
enough for the Cadillac 4.1L V-8, since Cadillac used the same basic
body as the Cadillac DeVille), but probably actually a bit better than
the 94 Cutlass (at least the rear plugs are reachable without a lot of
grief). And, the battery is in the engine compartment and not under
the rear seat like the new Aurora and the other "G" body cars.
If there is one thing that makes me a bit concerned about the
Intrigue is something it shares with most of the other FWD GM cars -
GM's crappy rear wheel disk brakes. GM does not seem to be able to
make rear wheel disk brake units that aren't a royal pain - that goes
back to the "E" and "K" bodies of the 80s and especially the "W"
bodies. I don't know what your experience has been on you Cutlass with
the rear brakes, but the Intrigue is likely to be about the same.
Maybe some folks with 98 or 99 Intrigues can add.some info about this,
but from what I've heard from owners of 98 and 99 Pontiac Grand Prix
(which is the same basic car), I'd consider the rear brakes a possible
problem area.
Like I said, overall I like the car: the main reason I would not buy
one is it is size - interior is too small for me (if I was buying a
new car right now, I'd be looking at the Pontiac Bonneville or the
Buick LeSabre).
Avis has quite a few of the Intrigues in their fleet (though they are
the lower-end models with cloth seats, though otherwise most of them
are loaded). I'd recommedn that, if you are thinking of buying one,
rent one for a week and see if you like it. Yep, I know that will cost
$200 or so, but if you find you don't like the car, it will save you
much more in grief over buying a car you don't like.
One final note: my next door neighbor is a Regional Manager for
Avis, and has driven the Intrigue and it's 3 equiv. GM models (Buick
Century, Pontiac GP and the Chevy Impala). Pete tells me he likes the
Intrigue the best of the 4, with the GP as #2.
Regards,
Bill Bowen
Daly City, CA