Question about 1995 Toyota Land Cruiser

1 Answer

Can a bad catalytic converter ruin a cylinder?

Can a bad catalytic converter ruin a cylinder in my 1995 land cruiser? just replaced them 5 years ago... now #6 cylinder is misfiring; i am told engine needs to be replaced!!

Posted by on

  • 1 more comment 
  • cooper2091 Aug 02, 2010

    that's what I thought about the cat. It was rattling and one mechanic put a clamp on it, said it was no big deal, and that we could get to it in the near future. No smoke, yet, but the check engine light came on while driving up a canyon. took it to another shop. they said they thought they knew what it was immediately, and didn't even check the cat. they said the compression was 80 and should be like 125 (?). then he said something about the cylinder and the rings... yikes!!! i know what you're saying about gouging.. i've had it happen and now i don't trust anyone and don't know where to take my cars :(

  • cooper2091 Aug 02, 2010

    he said they put some oil in there to see if the compression would come up; i believe they said it was 80, and they could only get it to come up to 90, but that lasted for like 10 mins and it started to go down again. also, the others were around 120-125 of the compression. He also mentioned the rings (I'm a dummy, sorry), the cylinder (or is that piston?) rings on #6, are bad; hence the no compression issue. THEN they said that it takes 11 hours to remove the head-- which he said it COULD be the valves or piston rings, or the head gasket-- but they'd have to get in there to see. BUT, to replace the engine is 20 hours, so I may as well replace the engine... WHAT??? that sounds strange to me...
    Error code originally was P0420 when I was told to replace the cats 5 years ago (2 shops told me that, one was the Toyota dealer here in town) and i believe i already had a mis-fire problem at that time, too (I was told to use Lucas upper engine lube). I'm thoroughly confused as to WHY the cats are burning out so quickly...

    I just called and he said the error codes were 300-- random cylinder mis-firing and error code 306-- specifically cyl #6

    thanks again.. sheesh, I wish you worked on toyotas here in utah...

  • cooper2091 Aug 02, 2010

    i meant ...120-125 ON the compression...



1 Answer

  • Level 3:

    An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points


    An expert that got 10 achievements.


    An expert that got 5 achievements.


    An expert whose answer got voted for 500 times.

  • Master
  • 1,857 Answers

NO, a cat only cleans up pollutants. It has no effect on engine performance unless you have a misfire and the cat works overtime and melts and cloggs the exhaust system. If your blowing grey smoke out the tailpipe then you indeed may have a bad engine. What I would want to know from the mechanic is what is the compression and why he thinks its a lower engine issue rather than a leaking valve on the head which would be alot less expensive to repair. Then again you could get a second opinion from another shop. Mechanic shops are known for gouging customers wallets, Not that i'm implying anything here.

Posted on Jul 31, 2010

Testimonial: "thank you for your quick reply!"

  • 6 more comments 
  • Susan Price Aug 02, 2010

    you know, checking compression is pretty easy. all you do is screw a compression tester into the spakplug hole and turn the engine over for about 4 umps with all the spark plus out. Do this to all the cylinders. If one is low squirt a few drops of oil into the cylinder and test again. If the compression does not increase then most likely you need a valve job. Oil will seal rings if the compression is an engine issue. Oil could seal a valve if the leak was real small but usually oil will not seal a vlave leak so compression will remain the same. Get the cylinder number that this mechanic tested as being low and if you choose to have another shop look at it DO NOT tell them aboutthe low compression. Lets see if they come up with the same conclusion. Also look at the spark plugs. If one cylinder was misfiring the sparkplug would look wet or black and sooty compared to the others.

    So what was the code ??. I'l dig deeper once I have more info.

  • Susan Price Aug 02, 2010

    well to begin with a misfire can cause a P0420 cat effeciency code by making it work overtime. A cat does have a life limit based on how clean the car runs so I can't fault anyone from making a bad call back then, but if the car had a misfire back then it should have been dealt with so as not to burn up the new cat. I see you have this listed as a 95. Some 95's are obd2 so I have to assume thats why your getting a 420 and misfire codes. It was mandatory all vehicles became Obd2 in 96.

    But now because you have compression issue the heads do need to be taken off to find the cause. The heads can be sent out and they will bolt the head down on a bench and test it. If any valves are leaking it should show up.

    I know its a bummer but I would hate to replace the whole engine if all you need is a valve job. Being this is a 95 I have to assume you have a good amount of miles on this and not knowing the history of the vehicle its not uncommon for engines to be replaced on alot of vehicle alot sooner than this.

  • Susan Price Aug 02, 2010

    by the way if your not getting a 420 code now then the cat is still ok, you just need to deal with the misfire issue.

  • cooper2091 Aug 03, 2010

    well, they didn't say anything about the 420 code-- but the cats were rattling like crazy and there are clamps on both now... (is that bad they're clamped?) it only has 165K miles :( My 1989 land cruiser (just had to get the fuel sys cleansed, different story, so we won't go there) has only 170K or so, and is rusty as hell.. maybe i should put that engine into the 1995, haha...

    Well, I'll have the heads pulled. I feel a lot better now, though, after our exchange, and your great feedback... yes, I wish the misfire was taken care of earlier, so this repair wouldn't be so costly. it could have been better maintained, but we've just been doing what they've been telling us to. I just had it tuned up (don't know why nothing was mentioned at that time, when they changed the plugs, I'm sure there was some evidence on the plugs-- but like I said, it's at a different shop now). I think it has missed a major tune up or two; my family usually drives stuff till it has a problem (! i know, gotta stop doing that).

    Thank you so much for your input. again, I wish you were here locally! Too bad... I don't understand why it's so hard to find a good and honest mechanic around here; and every time I do find one, it's short lived for one reason or another.

  • Susan Price Aug 03, 2010

    general engine theory is if any cylinder has more than 15% drop in compression you will have a misfire or rough running engine. If this is real your just going to have to bite the bullet and open you wallet to fix it.

  • cooper2091 Aug 12, 2010

    Hi again... hey, I'm gonna get another opinion, but I just wanted to ask you: if it turns out that it needs a valve job, what's the range of cost that appropriate for that? Today, I called one of the local toyota dealers and they asked if the other shop used a boroscope, which they didn't. I've had some problems with this particular dealer, and i doubt i'd have them do the work anyway-- but they said to diagnose, pull codes and plugs and check inside, etc: $165. another place said they'd pull the codes for free, then go from there... what do you think of all this? Please let me know when you can. Thanks again...

  • cooper2091 Aug 20, 2010

    by the way, my friend and husband were looking at the car.. it was a friggin loose spark plug wire. it wasn't snapped in all the way, and it had fallen out. I guess the wires aren't like other wires. thank goodness it was only that. it's only got 126k miles on it. thanks again for all of your help

  • Susan Price Aug 20, 2010

    its always good to hear a problem was never really a problem. I still question why anyone would of said you have low compression, A spark plug wire will not cause low compression unless you drove a longtime with the misfire and damaged your cylinder. Just hope this didnt happen



1 Suggested Answer

  • 2 Answers

SOURCE: I have freestanding Series 8 dishwasher. Lately during the filling cycle water hammer is occurring. How can this be resolved

a 6ya expert can help you resolve that issue over the phone in a minute or two.
best thing about this new service is that you are never placed on hold and get to talk to real repairmen in the US.
the service is completely free and covers almost anything you can think of (from cars to computers, handyman, and even drones).
click here to download the app (for users in the US for now) and get all the help you need.

Posted on Jan 02, 2017


Add Your Answer

Uploading: 0%


Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add



Related Questions:

2 Answers

Toyota land cruiser 1998 p0305

p0305 = Cylinder 5 misfire detected.
Check the coil wiring harness and connector plugs.

May 09, 2015 | 1998 Toyota Land Cruiser

1 Answer

2006 pacifica catalytic converter replace

The exhaust converter should last 12 to 14 years

So your vehicle has not had a happy life

Most likely many cylinder misfires & a rich fuel
condition & possible other issues have ruined the
converter,if it is even ruined

The question as you explained it leads me to believe
you don't have the tools & experience to do what needed
to be done to the exhaust system or diagnosing any OBD2
issues such as oxygen sensors

need a repair shop or dealer

Nov 27, 2012 | 2006 Chrysler Pacifica Touring

1 Answer

My cruiser feels like its running on 5 cylinders

Could need a tune up, have a bad catalytic converter, bad ignition coils, or a number of other things. Is the check engine light on? If you want to try and diagnose the issue, I will be happy to further assist you.

Mar 28, 2011 | Toyota Land Cruiser Cars & Trucks

1 Answer

Engine is suging real bad. at all speeds.

Mine did the same thing. I thought the fuel filter was clogged, but when I put on a new one, it did not solve the problem. I took it to my mechanic and he instantly knew what it was. He replaced the EGR valve. Fixed it. Also, a bad EGR valve can ruin a catalytic converter so you might want to check that also. I ended up replacing my catalytic converter right after the EGR valve was fixed. Got a catalytic converter that let the exhaust flow free-er. Getting 24 mpg on the highway now.

Feb 14, 2011 | 1995 GMC Jimmy

1 Answer

I have a 98 2.4 chevy cavaier. bottom at converter is getting red. changed plugs,wires, ignition coil,fuel filter,fuel regulator. Still getting red. What else could we check?

I am assuming that when you say bottom at converter you are refering to the catalytic converter in the exhaust if the converter itself or the inlet area of the catalytic converter is starting to glow red from heat it is because the converter itself is plugged up (bad) and needs replaced. If catalytic converter is bad and not replaced will ruin ignition system components such as plugs plug wires and such as well as intake sensors. I hope I understood your question properly.

Oct 02, 2010 | 1998 Chevrolet Cavalier

2 Answers

Just had a new cylinder head fitted to my 1997 toyota land cruiser , now its over heating what could be the problem .

It sounds like the head gasket is leaking and needs to be replaced. Keep in mind that the antifreeze is corrosive to the bearing to the engine so try to replace the gasket and engine oil soon as possible. Keep an eye on the oil level and condition, check to make sure that there is no antifreeze mixing with the engine oil. If your lucky, it could just be a bad thermostat and less work to replace the thermostat. Good luck

Nov 30, 2009 | 1995 Toyota Land Cruiser

1 Answer

Catalytic converter is bad on 1995 Subaru Legacy L Wagon

dearship parts are can buy a factory catalytic converter or universal converter cheaper at auto parts place.they basic the same parts the.dealership has same catalytic converter.they put their price and labor rate charge an hour your pocket book will be empty.i have used universal catalytic converter.had no problem with it.the only difference is universal converter body a little shorter.but has same lengh as factory.if check engine is coming on you cant turn it off .if computer showing you a could have a misfire causing rich exhaust emission.that can ruin a catalytic converter have it scan.dealership charge you about $130.00 .you can have it scan at advance auto or auto see what pcm code could be oxygen sensor somethinh minor.

Jul 12, 2009 | 1995 Subaru Legacy

Not finding what you are looking for?
1995 Toyota Land Cruiser Logo

400 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Toyota Experts


Level 3 Expert

76132 Answers

Colin Stickland
Colin Stickland

Level 3 Expert

22156 Answers

Jeff Turcotte
Jeff Turcotte

Level 3 Expert

8273 Answers

Are you a Toyota Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides