Question about Mini Cooper S

1 Answer

Got a new mini cooper s and horrible noise was coming from engine. took it to BMW and they said the camshaft has broke and all my valves need to be replaced Should i be worried

Posted by on

  • 1 more comment 
  • steves_2001 Oct 13, 2008

    The car would not start, had to get BMW services out to the car. the car has done 190000 miles and has a full service history

  • yadayada
    yadayada May 11, 2010

    You consider 190,000 to be a new car?? Hum very interesting

  • yadayada
    yadayada May 11, 2010

    And the question is?



1 Answer

  • Level 2:

    An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points


    An expert that got 10 achievements.


    An expert that got 5 achievements.


    An expert that has over 500 points.

  • Expert
  • 350 Answers

Hi if your camshaft had broke the car wouldn,t start and if the camshaft had broke the camshafts had a fault in it and it makes no sense what so ever cause if all your valves want changing the car wouldn,t start and if it did it would run very badly you are being took for a ride on this discription if you had a knocking noise from the top end of the engine the camshaft and rockers are proberly at fault may run like this for a long time or not but if i were you i would take it to another garage for a second opinion don,t mention about what bmw said something is not right here if this car is new then what mileage has it done and complain to bmw to fix it as this should not happen [free] these cams should last 100000 miles ifoil changes are done when they are suppose to good luck yates210456

Posted on Oct 13, 2008

  • paul yates Oct 13, 2008

    hi you said it was new so that said 190.000 miles but i stand by what i said if the cams broke then it won,t start get a second opinion but ifs done that type of mileage i would have the engine completly overhauled its not going to do much more just a comment for emmisionwiz nice to see you read others comments epspecially mine you will learn something so before you comment you should read what was posted which is i have a new mini cooper s not the reply to what i asked which was what is the mileage as obviously 190000 is not been done on a new vechicle which i didnt state steve2001 did



1 Suggested Answer

  • 2 Answers

SOURCE: I have freestanding Series 8 dishwasher. Lately during the filling cycle water hammer is occurring. How can this be resolved

a 6ya Mechanic can help you resolve that issue over the phone in a minute or two.
Best thing about this new service is that you are never placed on hold and get to talk to real repair professionals here in the US.
click here to Talk to a Mechanic (only for users in the US for now) and get all the help you need.

Posted on Jan 02, 2017


Add Your Answer

Uploading: 0%


Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add



Related Questions:

1 Answer

How do i reset camshaft servodrive on 2006 bmw 535xi

Hi Allen, In addition to removing the covers did you remove anything else? If not, reassembling should do the trick. If yours is the engine with VANOS and Variable valve lift (with electronically controlled motor, make sure all connection and pick up sensors are good. If you've lost spark and injection, check the crankshaft and camshaft pickup sensors. Regards John

Jun 19, 2014 | 2006 BMW 530xi Sedan

1 Answer

Whinning noise when engine is off

Whinning Causes
The whining noise you hear coming from the power steering pump is one of three things. The first is more of a loud "hush" than a whine; this is the sound of fluid rushing through the bypass valve when you turn the wheel all the way to one side or the other. Sometimes the bypass valve malfunctions or doesn't open all the way, causing pressure to back up in the pump and cause your engine rpm to drop. The second and third causes result from cavitation -- vacuum pockets created behind the rotor's vane blades as a result of extremely high pump action -- or air in the lines.

Nov 24, 2013 | 2003 Mini Cooper

2 Answers

Code p0014 exhaust and code p0015 exhaust

The code P0014 is for Camshaft Positon Sensor Actuator Bank 1. The possible causes are incorrect camshaft timing, wiring problems (harness/wiring) in intake timing control valve solenoid system; continuous oil flows to VCT piston chamber or failed timing valve control solenoid(stuck open).
The code P0015 is for Camshaft Position -Timing Over-******** (Bank 1). Your problem will probably be that the timing will be slightly out, due to wear (stretch) of the timing chain; this will all be linked to the overall cold start issue and the timing position. Get that timing checked, or push for the full fix for the cold start timing issue.

Jul 25, 2013 | 2007 Mini Cooper

1 Answer

My mini cooper surpintene belt broke and now i have rattle will this stop after i fix the belt

This depends if the tensioner was the problem, and thats why the belt broke in the first place it may need replaced. And if your talking about your engine is rattling this may not stop because the engine was over heated and this is the main cause of engine failure and blown heads.

Apr 07, 2012 | 2003 Mini Cooper

1 Answer

Exploded view mini cooper s motor 2002

BMW claims the Mini E draws a maximum of 28 kilowatt-hours from the grid per charge, and that this translates to approximately 5.4 miles per kilowatt-hour.
BMW Mini Prices

Nov 01, 2011 | 2000 Mini Cooper

1 Answer

Engine knocking noise in mini cooper s--gets louder on idle--and has gotten worse--

these have a Dual Mass Flywheel and could be the noise. Have a shop that knows MINI to check it for you. they are not cheap. You will need to replace the clutch also.

Dec 10, 2010 | 2007 Mini Cooper S Convertible

2 Answers

Front windscreen wipers have stopped working

Firstly check the fuses, if they are ok and you can here noise it will most likely be the linkage has popped apart, if no noise when on then check the switch.

*If you had cold weather when this happened, it is common for the motor to strain and blow the fuse*



Dec 18, 2009 | 2001 Mini Cooper

1 Answer


With ignition switch on and engine off activate a window switch... listen for a clicking noise. if there is no noise then start checking fuses and relays. The fuse panel in on the left of the drivers legs. open it up it is well marked and in it you will find a handy fuse puller and spare fuses if they're needed. If you hear the clicking sound then try the Mini cooper Thump. Apply it to the doors midway between the large and small speakers (It may take two or three solid thumps) re-apply as needed

Oct 20, 2009 | 2009 Mini Cooper

1 Answer

A constant whizzing

that whining noise is definately your power steering pump. the earlier models eg 2001-2003 just have noisy ones. so they say, if that noise become really excessive; its an early warning that its gonna fail. the newer pumps are much quiter, but i was quoted approx 1200+ CND for a new pump. I have a 2003 cooper, and the whining noise is loud. only once has the steering been really stiff, but i resolve that problem by restarting the vehicle. watch out tho, the power sttering could fail on you while your driving around a corner, and if you dont have both hands on the wheel, you'll go strait.

Sep 10, 2008 | 2003 Mini Cooper

6 Answers


If you have a Mini that was buit pre 2006 i.e. a first gen Mini then your new steering wheel will not fit, you need to buy a 1st gen Mini 3 spoke steering wheel.

Akso, for issues regarding the airbag light DO NOT pay the dealer silly amounts of money to solve the problem. Please visit the following thread

Jul 10, 2008 | 2003 Mini Cooper

Not finding what you are looking for?
Cars & Trucks Logo

Related Topics:

301 people viewed this question

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Mini Experts

Colin Stickland
Colin Stickland

Level 3 Expert

22306 Answers


Level 3 Expert

77499 Answers

Jeffrey Turcotte
Jeffrey Turcotte

Level 3 Expert

8826 Answers

Are you a Mini Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides